Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Edinburgh 14 – 43 Ulster

This game became a contest for about ten minutes in the second half, but otherwise it was easy street for Ulster as they shoved Edinburgh aside to top Conference A.

Ulster broke the deadlock inside the opening three minutes, although there was a whiff of a forward pass from hooker John Andrew as he broke down the right flank and fed Stewart Moore on the inside for a simple jog between the sticks.

When Edinburgh did get into Ulster territory they ran into the colossus that is Marcel Coetzee. He won two turnover penalties in the opening quarter, and the second eventually led to Ulster scoring again, as their maul – a facet of the game which head coach Dan McFarland had improved during his tenure at Glasgow Warriors – forced further infringements until Andrew himself crashed over.

The same set-piece bore fruit again to allow John Cooney a close range sniping score, with Edinburgh looking like an inflatable unicorn lost at sea. 25 minutes gone, and the writing already appeared on the wall.

Young full-back Jack Blain reduced the deficit in the 34thmin when he cut a nice line to scythe in, and fellow 20-year old Nathan Chamerlain converted to keep Edinburgh in the game.

A spill by Ally Miller from Cooney’s box-kick meant Ulster were then awarded the put-in at the scrum just outside the Edinburgh 22. Although Pierre Schoeman had been pinged the first time that the packs collided, he led the charge and referee Craig Evans’ blast of the whistle signaled an Edinburgh penalty.

A thumping kick to touch gave Edinburgh a platform to reduce the deficit further, but as had so often been the case in the first half, when they tried to spread the play through the backs, players were on different pages, leading to James Johnstone being called for crossing with time in the red.

Ian Madigan – Edinburgh’s scourge in last season’s Pro14 semi-final – went for a cheeky tap and go from half-way, but Matt Faddes sliced his chip over James Farndale and into touch to draw the half to a close.

Half-time: Edinburgh 7 – 19 Ulster

Whatever rockets Cockers fired at half-time seemed to work, as Edinburgh came out like greyhounds.

Ulster speed merchant Aaron Sexton spilled Johnstone’s grubber deep in his own 22 and Edinburgh didn’t mess about with the scrum.

Magnus Bradbury carried hard, and unlike in the first half they got support in to the breakdown to prevent the like of Coetzee getting onto the ball.

A surging run by Blain through James Hume took them closer, and a few phases later he was on hand to take Eroni Sau’s clever off-load and dive over. Chamberlain was successful with the conversion again to make it a 5-point game.

Consider momentum shifted. For now at least.

Nathan Chamberlain had a long-range strike at goal which cannoned off the post and although Farndale claimed the rebound and dived over, he was ahead of Chamberlain when the stand-off struck the ball. No try.

It was the correct call but a rather bitter pill to swallow seeing as Ulster’s first had been given without question.

Within about 5 minutes though, Edinburgh’s repeated indiscipline at the set-piece would see Cockerill asking for a hair transplant so he could pull it out again.

First it was Schoeman at the scrum (contentiously, but when aren’t they?) then Bradbury – not for the first time – with an early engagement to the maul.

Madigan kicked to 5m, Ulster held the jumper to milk the penalty but they didn’t need it. Jordi Murphy secured the bonus point try and Bill Mata was also sent to the bin for an accumulation of fouls at the line-out.

Ulster then showed that it’s not just the grunt work they can score from with a devastating move from seemingly out of nothing.

Inside their own half in centre-field, Madigan held off Crosbie, flicked the off-load to former Wallaby Sam Carter in acres of space and there on his shoulder was the exceptional Cooney to take his pass and tear away to the line, finishing the game as a contest.

Just because they found it so easy, Ulster’s Andrew scored from another short-range maul – which again saw Edinburgh infringe for an early engagement – and Andrew completed his hat-trick with a remarkable 50m sprint… just kidding, it all started with a maul again, and he dived over from close range.

The relentless march of the Irish provinces – aided by their government loaned pot of gold – in the Pro14 continues and with belts forced to tighten you can’t see how the Scottish pro sides can improve sufficiently to challenge this season and maybe beyond. Especially if you’re going to play into their hands by giving away countless penalties for the same offence.

SRBlog Player of the Match: two tries, dangerous running and excellent kick chase, young full-back Jack Blain. It couldn’t go to anyone in the pack.

Referee: Craig Evans (WRU)

6 Responses

  1. Cockers number is up. He should have gone when Edinburgh got papped out 2 comps in the space of a week and in such a meek manner. He has taken Edinburgh as far as he can, time to go.

  2. Overall completely physically overwhelmed by an impressive Ulster team, Marcel Coetzee was immense early doors.
    However for a 10min spell just after 1/2 time Edinburgh threatened to make a game of it, couple of rousing carries & an opportunist “try” brought the “scores level”, however a few mins later try chalked off, 14-31 & Mata yellow carded. Cherry, Johnstone & Blain did ok. I know a few guys unavailable but…………….
    No idea why Kinghorn, Toolis, Nel/Berghan, McInally weren’t released, unlikely to seen Edinburgh win but may have made us a wee bit more competitive

    1. I know it’s strange to say but I thought it was significantly better than the Leinster game. Obviously the disallowed try followed by the consecutive concession of 3 soft penalties resulting in YC, and try killed the game and then the score line got away from them. But for a decent chunk of the game they won collisions and got on the front foot. Chamberlain is improving fast as is Blain. Mata is back and cherry playing well.

  3. I reckon “line speed” has become the new term for offside. Like squint scrum feeds it is the law that is not enforced – it only seems to get called when a single player breaks from the defensive line but when the whole team is aligned somewhere in front of the back foot of the ruck then many refs don’t seem to be bothered. The teams that create such “line speed” create more turnover opportunities, stop their opponents getting over the gain line.

    Last night I thought Ulster were constantly allowed to stand in mid ruck, perhaps a yard in front of the back foot. The plays immediately before Edinburgh’s first try has Edinburgh battering the ulster line. In the ruck itself some ulster players were behind their own line, yet the standing defenders beside the ruck were standing well front of their line with one of them leaning on his hands like a sprinter which were placed well over a yard in front of the try line. This gives the defending team a huge advantage and refs need to do better in checking it.

  4. This is fairly torrid period for Edinburgh. I don’t think there are many out there who don’t acknowledge the impact that the test window has had though.
    It was a desperate start and I watched once again with the sense that some of the senior players were not leading the team well, when they are needed most. I was very impressed how we fought back into the game, and in particular by the resolve and determination of some of the young guys.
    No question Ulster deserved it, but there was one definite and one probable forward pass in the immediate build up to two of their scores.
    However, a poor box kick against a better counter attacking team is just an effective way to give up pressure and territory.
    There is a paucity of support in attack. Wider moves ending abruptly as no runner on the shoulder (reminds me of the national team in the Dark Days). Turnovers lost on the floor as a lack of support at rucks.
    I hope the test players will give the team a huge lift on their return – it’s been a tough shift.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Rory and Iain to look at the latest news including Scotland's win over Canada and the upcoming test against the USA.
Gregor Townsend has picked the strongest XV possible from his touring squad for the visit to Washington DC to play the USA, writes Rory.
Gregor Townsend has named his team to face Canada in the first match of the Skyscanner Americas Tour with 10 players given the opportunity to make their Scotland debut.
Craig is joined by Iain, Jonny and Rory to discuss Glasgow's momentous win in the final of the 2024 URC

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion