Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Which Type Of Scotland Fan Are You?

Edinburgh, UKR. March 13, 2016. Action from Scotland vs France in the RBS Six Nations Championship at BT Murrayfield Stadium, Edinburgh. (c) ALASTAIR ROSS | Novantae Photography Photo Credit: Alastair Ross / Novantae Photography

The stat man. This fan knows everything about the Scotland team. He knows who the kit man is. He knows how old every player in the squad is and can tell you to within 5% what the average attendance at Murrayfield has been over the last 10 seasons.
Most likely to say: “Duncan Taylor has better defending numbers than any of the other eligible centres.”

The Six Nations only fan.  Visible only in February and March of each year and then, like the wind, they are gone. This fan asks, “Why isn’t player x in the squad?” unaware that said player retired from International rugby in the autumn of the previous year (eg Laidlaw, G). This fan will have every item of Scottish Rugby kit but will never have set foot inside an actual rugby club. If this fan was an animal they’d be a grizzly bear. In hibernation for much of the year and only visible in the spring.
Most likely to say: “East 5 is a rubbish place to see the game”.

The #AsOne fan. They won’t countenance any criticism of the SRU or the players. Even if, like now Scottish Rugby is in disarray off and on the field they are blindly optimistic.  Anyone whose attitude doesn’t marry with theirs is told to just get behind the team. This fan is also the one who always bets for Scotland and is kept up-to-date on a number of betting sites offering bet 10 get 30 offers for the premier league and share it with his colleagues. Their one and only complaint will be about when the SRU send out their tickets. This fan will tell you that Gregor Townsend, or Toony as they insist on calling him, must be right because he is the coach. 
Most likely to say: “#InToonyWeTrust.”

The Long in the Tooth fan. This fan will be a member of a grass roots rugby club. I know this because they never fail to tell you right before they enlighten you that it wasn’t like this in their day. They are a ‘real’ rugby fan because apparently standing in the pissing rain beside a muddy field with 3 men and a dog is apparently a rite of passage.  If you get in a discussion with this fan about the game, you’ll probably get asked, “did you actually play rugby” in a patronising tone because playing for Old Pisspoorians 3rd XV or coaching mini rugby is akin to being on a par with Warren Gatland or Eddie Jones.
Most Likely to say: “the games gone soft”.

The Superficial Optimist whose bubble is easily burst. This person is in a group that suffers more than any other group of Scotland fans. In the run up to the Six Nations or the World Cup they will believe with all their heart and then when our opening game is an unmitigated disaster they will declare, “that’s it, I’m not wasting any more time on this shower” and they’ll maintain that demeanour until the next tournament by which time their bubble will have slowly refilled.  If this fan was furniture they’d be a garden swing. Our Editor is regularly one of these.
Most likely to say: “Grand Slam this year lads”.

The party animal. This person doesn’t actually care about rugby. They’ve been meeting their pals on the back pitches at Murrayfield every year since 1987 and someone will always get so drunk they’ll wake up In Llanelli in the back of a team bus. They’ll retell the drinking stories endlessly but they have to check the BBC Sport website to confirm what the score was. This is also the fan that will return to their seat in the 75th minute with 15 beers much to the delight of the older couple between his seat and the aisle. For this fan it’s all about the craic.  If this person was a holiday tour company they’d be Club 18-30.
Most likely to say: “Well we had fun, anyway”.

The blogger or podcaster. The worst of all Scotland fans. They’ll never admit it but secretly they hope Scotland are poor because it’s easier to pull something apart than put it together, and they know that ill-informed waffle dressed up as analysis brings more readers and listeners. In their hearts they wish they were Stephen Jones.
Most likely to say: “Yes, please send freebies”.

16 Responses

  1. Think I’m somewhere between a stat man and a superficial optimist.

    This is my prediction of what GT will pick. No my choices by far but half of them didn’t even make the squad.

    1. Sutherland
    2. Brown
    3. Nel
    4. Gilchrist
    5. Gray
    6. Ritchie
    7. Watson
    8. Bradbury
    9. Price
    10. Hastings
    11. Kinghorn
    12. Johnson
    13. Harris
    14. Maitland
    15. Hogg

    16. Mcinally
    17. Dell.
    18. Fagerson
    19. Cummings
    20. Cornelly Du Preez
    21. Horne
    22. Hutchinson
    23. Scott.

      1. Haha! Well said, Scrummo.

        Sadly I recognise my own traits in far too many of the above categories.

        Def feeling starting to feel a bit of the #AsOne coming on – though possibly as much a survival instinct as any real conviction.

      2. Right on SlowWalk. Could also be named ‘the Hater’. One memorable thrown intercept, missed tackle, missed touch, or otherwise not objectively supported preconception of an individual’s failings, and any number of standout or motm performances will not shake them of derision. Whilst flaky moments by other heralded players from within or abroad shall pass without comment. And certainly don’t let a player achieve international recognition, for then he’ll be just an ego, with no interest in the greater good of the team. Hope i’m not getting too #Asone here….


    (meant with love guys)

    1. The Team Lister
    most likely to say: ‘my xv made entirely of players above 100kg’
    2. The Ref-Blamer
    most likely to say: ‘Ben Whitehouse is the new Clowncy’
    3. The SQ Hipster
    most likely to say: ‘Jack Owlett on the bench for Wasps 2nds tomorrow’
    4. The Bring-Back-Vern -er
    most likely to say: ‘Townsends and Hogg’s egos have ruined Scottish Rugby!’
    5. The Hopeless Optimist
    most likely to say: ‘yeah but imagine next year when Kebble and Van Der Merwe are SQ….’

    1. This with main article pretty spot on, and like all of these types of fans as passes the day.

  3. Current climate on this blog suggests there should also be a “Doomsayer” fan included. This is the fan who takes disproportionate dislike to certain players and coaches, and links almost everything they have to say about rugby back to those individuals. Their predictions are always pointing to the worst case scenario, and of all the things they say, “I told you so” is their favourite.

    1. Ah, but without Laidlaw or P. Horne in the squad, they are in hibernation awaiting their next pariah.

  4. I am a “puzzler” as I believe I have a good knowledge of the game, how to develop players and a basic game plan to get the going and enjoying the challenge. I then watch the 6 nations and World Cup with heaps of hope and leave puzzled at what I saw…….still hoping besides the Bonus Gate & Finnexit hurdles.

  5. “Frustrated flanker” who cannot understand refereeing decisions at the breakdown, contests the offside line, appreciates a good turnover and detests anyone in the backs that generally does anything stupid. Occasionally pops up in the midfield to show the centres how to tackle. Doesnt mind who’s playing so long as we are winning. Enjoys a beer and an argument, although not as much as members of the “Front Row Union”

  6. What about the Jaded Veteran? Formerly a Superficial Optimist but who’s spirit has been crushed once too often. Most likely to be heard on 78mins at Twickers 2019 saying, “there’s still plenty of time for them to f**k it up!”

You might also like these:

Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards
Craig is joined by John on the injured reserve list to have a wee look at the URC action from the weekend.
World Rugby has taken steps to ban Dupont's Law amongst three new law changes to be brought in in July.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion