Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Scotland 20 – 24 Japan

Scotland Women Logo
© Scottish Rugby Blog

After last week’s scrum-infested snoozefest, those who braved the soggy Sunday weather were treated to a far more entertaining match, but another disappointing result.

Japan started by showing some nice interplay upon receiving kick-off, but once into Scotland territory conceded a penalty at the breakdown when Jenny Maxwell, assisted by Louise McMillan, latched onto the ball on the deck.

Having turned defence into attack, Scotland soon scored. They tried down the right-hand side, but Hannah Smith was stopped, however after a few forward rumbles, there was space down the opposite flank which allowed Megan Gaffney a simple score. Helen Nelson’s conversion was not so easy, so Scotland had to settle for the 5 points.

Japan struck back almost instantly, Noriko Taniguchi finishing after some powerful running from openside Kyoko Hosokawa and lock Yuna Sato had punched through the defensive lines. Ai Hirayama missed the equally difficult conversion to Nelson’s to keep the scores tied.

As assistant coach Bryan Easson had suggested last week, the free-flowing style of the visiting nations men’s team has obviously filtered down to the women. A sensational dart up the middle of the pitch by impressive centre Kanako Kobayashi left Scotland floundering, and although Rhona Lloyd did well to stop Anna Kasai just short of the line, Seina Saito was there to pick up from the base of the ruck and go over.

Japan were exhibiting fine handling, angled runs and team cohesion, whereas Scotland would make some inroads, then a poor kicking option or handling error would halt momentum. It really was just like watching the men’s game all over again.

Scotland though, managed to gain a foothold. As well as being mashed in the scrums last week, the line-out was also misfiring, but with captain Rachel Malcolm restored back to hooker, it was operating a lot more smoothly this week.

After consecutive penalties went to touch, Scotland mauled their way over the whitewash, Lisa Cockburn, in for the injured Megan Kennedy awarded the score. The conversion attempt by Nelson crashed off the outside of the post.

Scotland had one last roll of the dice before the half ended, but a knock-on halted the move after another surge from Hannah Smith had Scotland in a decent position.

Half-time: Scotland 10 – 10 Japan

Hannah Smith had looked Scotland’s most potent attacking threat, and 2mins into the second half she had the crowd roar her on as she powered through the tackles up to the Japan 22, but another knock-on stopped Scotland in their tracks.

Another Scotland spill in midfield gave Japan a great opportunity. With the ball kicked ahead, Chloe Rollie and Taniguchi were in a footrace, which Rollie won, but was then tackled over the try-line to award Japan a 5m scrum. The first one was held up, but Japan were eventually forced into the error due to some good Scottish line-speed, giving Maxwell the put in.

Rhona Lloyd took possession after the scrum and ghosted past her opposite number into the Japanese half, where they were awarded a penalty for offside. The attempt at the maul was hauled down, but when Nelson attempted a cross-kick they gave possession back to Japan. Fortunately, a forward pass to Sachiko Kato meant the ball was returned to Scottish hands in a decent attacking position.

Smith and Rollie provided the dancing feet, Bonnar and Konkel the power. Konkel was stopped just 5m shy, but the ball was spun out left where Megan Gaffney was on hand to grab her second try of the afternoon.

Japan had realised they were getting hammered at the line-out, but an attempt at a cute, short one ended up in a spilt pass and being played from an offside position. Scotland kicked to touch and again were able to maul themselves over the try-line through captain Rachel Malcolm.

A high tackle by Lisa Thomson gave Japan a penalty on the Scotland 10m line, which they opted to scrum rather than take to the line or have a pop at goal. They spun it wide as early as possilbe, but Rollie pulled off a textbook piece of one-on-one defending on Kasai, using the touchline as assistance.

Japan had managed to hold onto possession though, and after another pair of scrums, eventually Makoto Ebuchi forced the ball on to the posts after a series of pick and gos. Perhaps crucially, with only seven minutes remaining, it was also the first converted score of the match.

And so it proved. After Scotland conceded a contentious penalty, when it looked like Japan’s Sora Konishi had made a double movement in the previous phase, Ayasa Otsuka was able to weave her way in under the sticks. The conversion made it 20-24 with only seconds remaining. Japan claimed the restart, took the ball into contact, checked with referee Munarini, and thumped it into the stands to leave Scotland 0 for 2 in the autumn.

Referee: Clara Munarini (FIR)

SRBlog Player of the Match: Hannah Smith. The most dangerous runner in the Scotland team, and didn’t seem to miss too much in terms of defence.

Attendance: 2, 263

6 Responses

  1. Hannah Smith deserves the player of the match. Her power was a significant factor for Scotland. However, Japan looked technically much better. The service from 9 was quicker (not picking the ball up before passing), there were more attacking options (good use of inside ball) and their passing was much more precise. There is no reason we can’t get these things right in the men’s and women’s teams from junior rugby up. There is a lot to learn from how Japan play – also really interested to know how they have improved so much.

  2. I think this is generally the most depressing Scottish rugby has been this decade. It’s the lack of hope.

    1. What!?!? We got knocked out of the 2011 RWC group stages in far worse fashion after failing to score a try against Georgia. We’d fielded Dan Parks and Phil Godman at 10.

      We’re much better at test level and pro-team level, and have better pro pathways than a decade ago. We’ve had an awful 18 months but we are nowhere near the doldrums of the relatively recent past.

      1. I agree with FF. It seems bad just now but that’s because, relatively speaking, it was going pretty well a year or two back. It’s nowhere near the dark times of previous decades. Have a dig through the archive if you want to see some examples of real false optimism!

    2. I think it’s more depressing because:
      – National team: talented 10 playing in Paris, 2 at Exeter, 2 at Saracens, 1 at Toulouse, best part of a pack at Edinburgh, best part of backs at Glasgow, plus loads others and the only position wanting is LH.
      – But zero hope GT brings them together in the right way.

      – Because with Horne, Hastings, Tagive, Johnson, Jones, DTH, Seymour. There’s a backline and with Gibbins, Gray, Kebble and GR, Fagerson brothers, Brown there’s enough up front.
      – But zero hope DR (who has one foot out the door anyway) brings them together in the right way.

      – Cockerill is bringing them together in the right way! The one bright spot in Scottish rugby.
      – But they always lose to Munster.

      – Dodson might fight the corner against force majeur
      – But that doesn’t stop them picking fights with players families or many others acts of stupidity.

      At least in 2011 you could laugh, now we’re squandering talent and it is depressing. Neither team has a crack in Europe or the league and we’ll be fighting for the wooden spoon come Spring.

You might also like these:

Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards
Craig is joined by John on the injured reserve list to have a wee look at the URC action from the weekend.
World Rugby has taken steps to ban Dupont's Law amongst three new law changes to be brought in in July.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion