Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Wales U20 18-15 Scotland U20

Scotland Logo © SRU - used with permission

Scotland Under 20s were without Adam Hastings (who was recalled to start for Bath alongside Niko Matawalu) Jamie Ritchie and Blair Kinghorn (both on Edinburgh duty) and  but you wouldn’t have known it from the strong first half performance at Colwyn Bay where both sides were chasing their second win of the U20 Six Nations.

The Welsh were a solid looking bunch but fullback Ruaridh Howarth and hooker Jake Kerr carried well in the opening exchanges. Things sparked into life when Rory Hutchinson set Howarth on a mazy run before a high arcing pass to 13 George Taylor sent him sprinting down the line. Perhaps a little more take and give might have made more of the overlap but the charging Scots forwards kept the pressure on and earned a penalty that was calmly slotted by Hutchinson.

Scott Cummings and his pack looked well drilled by Coach John Dalziell and put in several strong mauling efforts in the first half, including two almost unstoppable tries one for openside Matt Smith and one for loosehead Murray McCallum just before half time.

For the Welsh Dan Jones missed a penalty attempt but in between the Scottish scores there was plenty of breathless end to end rugby and only a superb covering tackle from Smith kept Keelan Giles out in the corner. The hosts had a mauling try of their own from the ensuing lineout to narrow the scoreline but Dalziell would have been pleased how his young men responded to stretch out the lead again with McCallum’s try.

Half-time Wales U20 5-15 Scotland U20

Reuben Morgan-Williams at 9 was a livewire for Wales and his darting runs from the base of the ruck showed what a good attacking scrum-half can do. It got the Welsh moving until captain Tom Phillips battered over from close range. Again though, Jones missed the conversion.

The Welsh were more grimly more determined in a second half that you fancy was more what they had in mind for the way this game should go, with their running lines causing concern for the Scottish defenders and hard tackling forcing too many turnovers.

Some great soft hands from the Welsh backs put winger Giles over in the corner for a textbook try perhaps aided by some muddled defending in the wider channels. All of a sudden it was 15-15 and the clock was running down while Scotland looked barely able to register an impact in the second half.

A great break by the impressive Hutchinson and utility back Ben Robbins took Scotland down into the Welsh 22 for a rare chance in the half but the Welsh scramble defence managed to get it clear, and from an attacking lineout minutes later the pack couldn’t exert the dominance they had in the first half and Wales were off the hook.

Almost inevitably, Wales had a kickable penalty from almost nothing with just moments left to play, and with Jones looking a little uncomfortable from a previous tackle, replacement Billy McBryde (son of Robin) slotted the left-footed kick to snatch back the lead at the worst possible time for Scotland.

The young Scots can be proud of their dominance but a worrying national trait re-emerged when they were so much poorer in the second half.

SRBlog Man of the Match: Rory Hutchinson directed traffic well and the range of kicks in behind from the Scottish backs was better than you normally see from the senior team. However for his try, a try saving tackle and a strong ball carrying performance Matt Smith was the standout.

Scotland U20 Team:
15. Ruairi Howarth
14. Darcy Graham
13. George Taylor
12. Tom Galbraith
11. Robbie Nairn
10. Rory Hutchinson
9. Hugh Fraser
1. Murray McCallum
2. Jack Kerr
3. Callum Sheldon
4. Callum Hunter-Hill
5. Scott Cummings
6. Andrew Davidson
7. Matt Smith
8. Ally Miller

16. Lewis Anderson, 17. Goerge Thornton, 18. Adam Nicol, 19. Stephen Ainslie, 20. Scott Burnside, 21. Charlie Shiel, 22. Chris Lines, 23. Ben Robbins

3 Responses

  1. A creditable performance, I am still hopeful we can match last year’s showing of three wins. I am frankly surprised we got so close, given four top guys were out & I watched Wales dismantle the Irish last week. Close but no Ceegar.

  2. Despite the loss, seriously encouraging stuff. It’s a hugely talented and composed group of players we have – The U20 WC is going to be really interesting w/ England in our group. Can’t wait to have Scott Cummings, Matt Smith & Andrew Davidson in the Glasgow squad.

    They are really well coached at the set piece. Pity they aren’t quite powerful enough at the scrum without Fagerson – I think that cost them the game ultimately.

    Hutchinson is a superbly composed player, did really well to cover the absence of Kinghorn and Hastings but their presence was clearly missed in terms of Scotland’s all round attacking game.

  3. I totally agree. I wonder if the national psyche would have been better served with Fagerson going back for a game, and Embra “instructed” about their guys.

    We might just have thrown away an opportunity to really enthuse the youngsters. An under 20 TC on the cards.

    Still, next I want to see how Hastings goes for Bath. With Nico as his SH!!!

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Rory and Iain to look at the latest news including Scotland's win over Canada and the upcoming test against the USA.
Gregor Townsend has picked the strongest XV possible from his touring squad for the visit to Washington DC to play the USA, writes Rory.
Gregor Townsend has named his team to face Canada in the first match of the Skyscanner Americas Tour with 10 players given the opportunity to make their Scotland debut.
Craig is joined by Iain, Jonny and Rory to discuss Glasgow's momentous win in the final of the 2024 URC

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion