Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Three Simple Fixes

Scotland coaching staff - pic © Al Ross
Scotland coaching staff - pic © Al Ross

Four defeats from four, with the championship favourites to come.

Another disappointing defeat follows as sure as the seagull follows the trawler, and Scotland’s improving form of the Autumn has been replaced by the cold reality that there has been no big leap forward when it really comes to the crunch.

They have performed well in patches and there are some positive signs in amongst the bilge. On Saturday against England, after a horrific first 20 minutes, there was a display of real guts to get back into the game when it would have been easy to capitulate.

The frustrating thing for Scottish fans is that there are some straightforward issues which, if resolved and stuck to, would give the team a much stronger foundation and are all entirely within the power of the players and coaches. If they want to turn the results around, someone needs to stop Scotland from watching Barbarians video’s from the 70’s.

Here are the top three fixes I would make:

Get up to speed

Scotland at the restart have been very poor. The game against England was the prime example of an issue which has effected Scotland across the 6 Nations. You can’t start the each half on the back foot and with a lack of intensity. The level of precision needs to increase (no more kick offs into touch please!) and the level of controlled aggression needs to be taken up a notch for the full 80.

Scotland won’t win the game in the first 5 minutes but they can certainly lose it – the lack of organisation and intensity against the English was criminal, and could have seen the game out of sight before everyone had taken their seats. Send them out early to hit some bags and get the blood pumping again!

Think before you kick!

All too often in this 6 Nations the game plan has been to put up high kicks that can be competed for. As pointed out by Mike Blair in his, as ever, excellent BBC Online article, this is a solid tactic in theory however when performed as badly as it has been by Scotland across this tournament then it’s counter effective. All Scotland have managed to do is give away easy possession and position.

Saturday’s game had multiple examples of kicks that went too long and the likes of Mike Brown were running at full tilt by the time the Scotland kick chase were up with play. Scotland would be better served to start to play the percentages and kick for touch more regularly.   The lineout is mostly reliable these days and always provides an opportunity for turnover ball. When playing in the opposition’s half Scotland have looked decent but they are not there long enough to build any pressure.

The best sides are happy to concede possession if the opposition will get the ball inside their 22, knowing that the pressure of having the ball so deep will often lead to mistakes, penalties or easy concession of the ball.

Keep it simple, stupid!

Scotland have been at their best when they have played a simple game plan.

Good lines, sucking in multiple defenders, and then quick ball through the hands.

It worked in Paris, and again resulted in a try at Twickenham. Like a rolling maul, when done well it is highly effective, and frustratingly difficult to stop. Unfortunately too many times Scotland tried to score on every phase rather than appraising the game more widely – this results in panic passes or poor decision making.

Have an overlap? Pass the ball through the hands so it stays an overlap, rather than a high, long miss pass which slows the attack down and allows the defenders to come across.

Have to defend a setpiece attack? Stick in the line and don’t bolt out.

The worry is that some of the stuff Scotland would benefit from thinking about is the stuff every club up and and down the country would do as standard in pre-season.

6 Responses

  1. I dont think there is anything i dont agree with! Now, can they bloody well do it next week? I hope so!

    I do suspect that someone somewhere must have run over a black cat judging by the horrendous ill luck with injuries Scotland have!

  2. Agree with the points made Al.
    The start they made against England was so lethargic I couldn’t quite believe it. This was against a backdrop of English reporting in the press, saying England had to make a fast start which they hadn’t done in any previous game. It isn’t as if we didn’t know what was coming.

    I do wonder what has happened in second half of all the Scotland games. The opposition seems to collectively say, we’ll just ‘squeeze them’ and keep it tight. They’ll make schoolboy mistakes if we do this for long enough.
    As Scotland managed to pressurise Wales for the last 10 minutes at the end of the game, it can’t be a fitness issue. I wish someone would tell me what is happening here? A collective brain freeze?

    Why can’t Scotland start a half fast?

  3. Couldn’t agree more Al, no point overcomplicating the analysis. Get the basics right first, doesn’t seem to be anything overly complex which is losing us games just poor game management and lack of concentration at times. Scotland are hugely sporadic, good spells and bad spells – we lose games when we tone down the intensity. Ireland will start hard and fast on Saturday as they need a win and a margin of victory to put them in contention. First 15mins will be crucial.

  4. I agree with some of this but I would add the following:

    1. practice the game by not kicking at all. Drill it into the players that they should only kick to touch when in trouble (e.g. last defender at own 5m line) and avoid garryowens or box kicks at all cost. Show the team footage of what goes wrong when we use this tactic- i.e. we only gain 5 yards tand the ball goes straight back to the opposition.
    2. play with a much higher tempo, particularly the forwards
    3. VC shouold field strong heavyweight guys in the forward pack to give us a fighting chance.

    Do these three things and we will win games.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards
Craig is joined by John on the injured reserve list to have a wee look at the URC action from the weekend.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion