Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


A Team Squad Sees Reshuffle (and no Roddy)

Greig Tonks
Greig Tonks - pic © Al Ross

Glasgow Warriors’ assistant coach Shade Munro has been named today as head coach of Scotland A for their game against England Saxons at Scotstoun Stadium later this month.

Munro has been given the reins once again after leading Scotland A to their first win on English soil at that level, beating the Saxons 13-9 in Newcastle last February.

He will be assisted by fellow Glasgow coach Kenny Murray and Edinburgh Rugby assistant coach Stevie Scott for the match on Friday 31 January (kick-off 7.30pm).

Today the trio named a 23-man squad for the fixture, comprising 12 Glasgow Warriors, six Exiles and five from Edinburgh Rugby, including a fair selection of Edinburgh’s new Scots’ qualified imports.

Five of the A squad are currently training with the senior Scotland squad and Munro and Scotland head coach Scott Johnson are liaising closely to give both national teams – Scotland open their RBS 6 Nations campaign against Ireland in Dublin two days after the A match – the best chance of success.

Johnson and Munro also subscribe to the belief that the A team is a means of finding out whether players are ready and able to win promotion to the senior side, whether now or in the future. Those of us hoping that Greig Tonks might be given a run at 10 during the tournament will be disappointed to see his name included here. Those of us hoping to see Roddy Grant or John Barclay’s names might be something close to anger…

Shade Munro said: “This is a game the players and supporters all look forward to as it’s a one-off match and it’s fantastic that we’re playing the game in Glasgow this year for the first time.

“I’m delighted to have been named head coach once again and after last year’s victory down in England and our success at Netherdale two years ago, we’re looking to try to continue our good record against the Saxons.”

The squad comprises ten players who would be making their first appearance for Scotland A – forwards Olly Atkins, Fraser Brown, Kevin Bryce, Blair Cowan, Jonny Gray, Tyrone Holmes and Kieran Low; and backs Byron McGuigan, Mark Bennett and Grayson Hart. Gray and Brown already have full caps.

At the opposite end of the experience spectrum is Ally Hogg, the 48-times full-capped back-row forward, who celebrated his 31st birthday yesterday.  Hogg has not played for Scotland since the 2009 RBS 6 Nations Championship and, indeed made his Scotland A debut against Romania, 12 years ago, but his form at Newcastle Falcons has been monitored closely by the coaches.

Elsewhere, two younger forwards who won full caps during the viagogo Autumn Tests, former Scotland under-20 captain Jonny Gray and London Irish back-rower Kieran Low, are listed, Gray having worked hard to be ready to return from injury, while three of the props who featured in last year’s heroic victory at Kingston Park, Jon Welsh, Gordon Reid and Grant Shiells, are primed for front-row duty.

In the backs, Richie Vernon’s rapid education as a centre three-quarter, continuing his transformation from a back-row forward, is set for another step-up.

Munro added: “We’ll be coming together as a squad next week. I’m pleased with the mix of promising young talent and hard-nosed experience that we have in the squad and we’ll look forward to performing at Scotstoun.”

Kenny Murray, who made the step up from club rugby to professional rugby in July when he joined the Warriors from Ayr, has been given the opportunity to coach a national squad for the first time.

Murray said: “I’m honoured to have been asked to help coach Scotland A this year. I’ve really enjoyed the last six months at the Warriors and this is another big opportunity for me.

“It will feel very familiar working with Shade (Munro) and playing the game at Scotstoun and I’m looking forward to working alongside Stevie (Scott) for the first time.”

Stevie Scott said: “It will be good to be involved with Scotland A again and hopefully we can build on last year’s fantastic win down in England.”

Tickets for the game at Scotstoun are on sale now and start from £10 for adults with all under-18 tickets just £5. They can be booked online at or and over the phone by calling 0844 800 3490 (Monday to Friday, 9am-5pm).

Scotland A squad:  Forwards – Olly Atkins (Edinburgh Rugby), Fraser Brown, Kevin Bryce (both Glasgow Warriors), Blair Cowan (London Irish), Jonny Gray, Robert Harley (both Glasgow Warriors), Allister Hogg (Newcastle Falcons), Tyrone Holmes, Ed Kalman (both Glasgow Warriors), Kieran Low (London Irish), Gordon Reid (Glasgow Warriors), Grant Shiells (Newcastle Falcons) and Jon Welsh (Glasgow Warriors)

Backs – Mark Bennett (Glasgow Warriors), Jack Cuthbert, Dougie Fife (both Edinburgh Rugby), Alex Grove (Worcester Warriors), Grayson Hart (Edinburgh Rugby), Tom Heathcote (Bath Rugby), Byron McGuigan, Henry Pyrgos (both Glasgow Warriors), Greig Tonks (Edinburgh Rugby) and Richie Vernon (Glasgow Warriors)

8 Responses

  1. Heathcote is the only specialist ten in the team so I wouldn’t be surprised if Tonks was given a go, maybe even starting at ten with Heathcote on the bench. I’m definitely close to anger with the Roddy Grant snub, multiple man of the match awards this season and he’s overlooked for a London Irish player. I guess they just want him tied to Scotland

    1. Am I imagining things or did Low not come on in one of the autumn internationals thus he is tied already?

    2. Aye Low did but Cowan didn’t, Low is a lock/flanker but from what I’ve read Cowan plays across the back row which I guess is the reason he’s in over Roddy Grant. Doesn’t help with the frustration though

  2. One or two surprising selections again in this squad. ‘A’ caps being handed out to ‘tie’ people to Scotland? Olly Atkins, Grayson Hart, Blair Cowan, Tyrone Holmes? Not only disappointing for Roddy Grant, to be overlooked for Cowan and Holmes, but what about Fraser McKenzie, a regular at Newcastle and surely a better player than Olly Atkins? Hart came with a big reputation from NZ and is beginning to show his form now, but again it could be argued that other boys like Sean Kennedy and Sam Hidalgo Clyne are being held back to get Hart tied. Richie Vernon is being promoted very quickly – he made a great break against Toulon on Saturday, but then showed his inexperience at centre by failing to take advantage of the 2 on 1 to put Hogg in for a try. There are a few boys doing well in the championship who maybe deserve a try at this level too – Stevie McColl, Lee Millar, to name just two.

    1. From what I’ve seen of Hart, its only Laidlaws kicking form thats keeping him out of the Edinburgh team.

  3. I don’t like to derail the thread, but for lack of suitable alternatives I thought it would be acceptable to post here.

    Has anybody else heard the rumours and whispers that the English, Welsh and Scottish have a agreement in principle over a British Premier League to replace the English Premier League and Rabo League? Presumably if the Irish come on board it would become a British and Irish league, and perhaps the Italians would be allowed a team or two in the French structure?

    An interesting development if it comes to fruition…?

    1. I doubt everyone would be happy with that deal, it would mean cutting teams from each league as even without the Italians there are still over twenty teams in that prospective league, I don’t expect the Irish would be too keen on getting rid of Connacht and likewise I could see the English pushing for one of the Scottish teams to be dropped. It could work if some rabo teams were put into a league with some from the championship although I don’t really know how that would be decided

    2. I haven’t read about any rumours but I have seen a lot of discussion BTL on plenty of forums. I think the suggestion is a 2 or 3 tier (or occassionaly conference) system with promotion and relegation, tier 1 goes into HC, tier 2 goes into Amlin, and potentially English Championship becomes tier 3.

      For Scotland and Wales it has the advantage that you could start up cheap pro-teams and begin them in the third tier without the necessity for huge wage bills. The risk is obviously that Scotland or Wales will face having some or all of their pro-teams relegated below the top tier. Personally, I think that would be a worthwhile price to pay as the second tier of a British league would get more attention and be more lucrative than the pro-12 and there would be greater scope for Scottish players to play for teams throughout the UK and not fear disappearing off the SRU radar.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion