Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Weir Finds Plenty To Work On

Duncan Weir - pic © Al Ross
Duncan Weir - pic © Al Ross

Scotland fly-half Duncan Weir rued his side’s errors as they slumped to a 28-0 defeat to South Africa at Murrayfield on Sunday. Over the past two weeks the Glasgow Warriors 10 has injected some much-needed verve and urgency into the Scottish attack during his second-half cameos replacing counterpart and club-mate Ruaridh Jackson.

While his spell against South Africa was marred by a couple of nervy errors, the game against Japan saw him score his first try for his country, a memory that brings a smile to his face.

“It was an amazing feeling, one that I’ll treasure for the rest of my life and I’m just delighted it was here at Murrayfield as well.”

Although from very short range, it wasn’t the easiest try to score with a diving reflex catch required to snatch the Sean Maitland’s offload as it bounced off a defender’s shoulder.

“I’m pretty confident with the zero-metres gained ball carry sort of try,” he jokes. ” I’m just delighted I followed up my pass and got on the good end of it for the try.”

Weir traditionally had a reputation as more of a kicking standoff, but over the last few seasons he has invested a lot of time shedding that image.

“I feel over the last couple of seasons my running game and passing has been improving with every chance that I’ve been on the pitch. Especially with Johnno being a standoff himself, he really drives us hard and it’s really reaping the benefits on the pitch. [He’s] pretty certain on what he wants from his ten,” adds Weir.

“It’s just a matter of who can take their chance in the jersey, and put what he wants into practice.”

“It’s all about taking the opportunities he gives.”

Weir was given another opportunity with twenty minutes against South Africa that saw a mixture of good and bad, much like most of his teammates. He did vary the game nicely and showed those kicking boots with an intelligent cross-field grubber kick that almost saw Max Evans touch down in the corner.

Though it would have restored little more than a shade of respect to the scoreline, Evans’ effort was ruled out by the TMO, consigning the Scots to their first pointless defeat since a 40-0 loss to New Zealand in the 2007 World Cup.

And while crediting the physical Springboks’ defence, the 22-year-old stresses the importance of stamping out the mistakes that so hampered the hosts’ go-forward.

“We’re all good enough rugby players not to make silly mistakes like that,” Weir tells us post-match.

“But that comes down to South Africa’s pressure as well. It’s something we can look and learn from.

“Under that amount of pressure, there are going to be mistakes from the attacking side, and that was certainly the case today.”

With poor weather conditions and a playing surface afflicted by parasitic worms, Weir praises the way the Boks rearguard suffocated their hosts’ attack.

“In the first half, they played the conditions really well, the pressure mounted, and we couldn’t get anything going,” says Weir.

“When I came on, although we had the majority of the territory, their defence was just outstanding.

“Everybody was getting lined up pretty well; they’re hugely physical in the tackle area.”

Weir came on with the Scots already staring at a 28-point deficit, and while he was largely satisfied with his own performance, admits the team struggled through a lack of cohesion and ruthlessness.

“Personally, there were mistakes in there, but a few nice touches off the boot,” acknowledges Weir.

“As an overall team performance, we couldn’t execute anything – on that front, it was disappointing.”

The diminutive fly half has come through the ranks at Cambuslang and Glasgow Hawks to find himself one of Scotland’s top choices in the pivotal ten shirt, and is taking nothing for granted. And his chief rival is also his clubmate.

“Me and Jacko have a good relationship, we’re not bitter in our relationship at all. We’re both driving to be the best players possible. You can only take your opportunities when they come, because you know there is a guy sitting on the bench who is going to fill the jersey and compete for your place. It’s really up to you to fulfil it because if you don’t perform you know you’re not going to get the jersey next week.”

Fresh-faced even at 22, the only area Weir concedes ground to his rival is in the facial hair department, with Jackson currently sporting a colonial era set of whiskers.

“No unfortunately he can beat me on moustaches, I’m trailing a long way behind on that front.”

Additional reporting: Rory Baldwin

4 Responses

  1. Coming on when you’re 28 – 0 down it’s inevitable that you’re going to try and force things, maybe take a few risks and generally try to make something happen. The only real errors on Sunday were the near inerception and the missed penalty kick to touch when trying to nail it right in the corner – had the game been tighter I don’t think he would have tried either.

    I haven’t seen much of Weir domestically, but he does seem to be a far better passer of the ball – really zips the passes and obviously his kicking game is superior. I’ve listened to hacks spouting tripe about Jackson being a running stand-off and Weir being just a kicker – but a quick t’interweb search finds far more Weir tries that Jackson ones so not sure that really is the case anymore.

    Anyway, hope Weir gets a chance to start on Saturday and that both Weir and Jackson continue to push each other to greater things.

  2. Just seen the squad announcement for Saturday’s game against Australia. As a defender of SJ’s reign so far I must say I’m shocked and disappointed.

    1. MacArthur isn’t starting.
    2. Ross Ford is!
    3. Fusaro isn’t getting an appearance AT ALL during these AIs. SJ could easily have let Denton have a rest, put Beattie at 8, started Brown in his ACTUAL position and finally given Fusaro a start.
    4. NO no.7 again despite now having two fit open side flankers.
    5. Grant Gilchrist is on the bench instead of Jonny Gray.
    6. Ross Ford has STILL not been dropped. WTF!

    Really dreading his announcement of the starting backs. Slamont at FH maybe!?!How about Ruaridh Jackson at centre!?! Really not looking forward to this game now and it is one we should be targeting for a win. Oz are tired, they have half their team out and we need a morale boost.

    I liked that SJ talked about giving people a chance and developing a squad but the sad thing is he could have done that without making these bonkers changes and just playing people in their actual positions. What on earth must Fusaro and MacArthur be thinking?

  3. FF, couldn’t agree more though I’m trying hard not to be disappointed and to just wait and see how it plays out (I’m going to the game too…). You never know (usual Scottish optimism).

    I see one of Australia’s key play makers, Matt Toomua, is out after pulling his hamstring in training. Shame, all in all, it’s looking less and less like a good game to see.

  4. And, of course, if Scotland do win, there’ll be the usual jibe that it was just against a second (or third) string side.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion