Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Has Scottish Rugby Gone Mad?

Scott Johnson, Vern Cotter, Mark Dodson - pic © Scottish Rugby/SNS
Scott Johnson, Vern Cotter, Mark Dodson - pic © Scottish Rugby/SNS

I imagine more than a few people wondered this week: had Scottish Rugby taken leave of its senses?

This week they announced that Vern Cotter, 51, a New Zealander by birth, and currently the head coach with French Top 14 club Clermont Auvergne, will take the reins of Scotland.

He has been with Clermont Auvergne since 2006, directing them to the French championship in 2010 and a Heineken Cup final earlier this month. Prior to his post in France, Cotter was part of the coaching set-up that steered Canterbury Crusaders to successive Super rugby titles in 2005 and 2006. So far, so good. He’ll be perhaps be familiar with Mark Bennett and Sean Maitland then.

However I must have missed the moment last year when Manchester United announced that David Moyes had been secured to take over from Fergy, but they would have to wait a year until he could finish his business with Everton.

I suppose that illustrates just how unlike Manchester United Scottish Rugby is on the global stage. We got our man, but we can’t have him when we most need him. Yup: he doesn’t take up the post full-time (if international coaching is ever full-time) until the summer of 2014.

This time next year.

Make no mistake, now is the time to rebuild. We have a squad starting to show promise, and 2 years out till the World Cup. Players that could be key for experience (see below) are getting the surgery out of the way now. Time to start putting the plan into action, not just in place.

When Cotter takes over there will be a summer tour of some sort which he may or may not miss, then the Autumn Tests, a solitary Six Nations and, er, that’s it. Scott Johnson will steer until then, with the SRU seemingly unwilling (or unable) to buy Clermont out of the contract. Whip round, anyone?

Seriously though, with the money on the table for the salary couldn’t we find a sponsor to stump up the extra cash?

We no doubt attract plenty of candidates but they are the same Eddie O’ Sullivans we always hear trotted out when there is a vacancy. Yesterday’s men. The ideal men, such as Wayne Smith, Ewen Mackenzie or Todd Blackadder all have eyes on Test-level jobs a little closer to home. Cotter belongs in their company as a future international coach but to secure a proper candidate we have had to take it on his terms – or rather Clermont’s terms.

There have been rumours of leaving early or resignations, but these are just that and denied by the man himself who intends to see out his term in France. Honourable then, but not much use to us till next year except during International Windows – and we know how sniffy the French clubs are about those.

Still, when he arrives – and we hope it’s “when”, and not “sorry I won the double with Clermont and got the All Blacks job” – we wish Vern all the best as head coach of Scotland. As he says in the video below, he’ll need to hit the ground running.

Video courtesy Scottish Rugby

Just as we debate whether or not it is possible to be both stupefied, chuffed and worried all at the same time comes the news that John Barclay, the 41-times-capped Scotland flanker and the only proper openside in the tour party at the moment, will miss Scotland’s tour to South Africa next month.

Barclay underwent surgery on a shoulder injury today, which was sustained during the season.  His hospital appointment precedes him joining the Scarlets in the new season.

At this juncture, the SRU have announced, Barclay will not be replaced in the party, which is now 30 strong. It’s quite a big blow given the form he displayed towards the end of the season after being restored to his preferred 7 shirt having spent a fair bit of time doing what we could refer to as the Kelly Brown shuffle. Ironically his chances came as Chris Fusaro – who kept him on the move – got injured. Now both men are on the sidelines and a lot rests on the aforementioned Brown’s shoulders. It might however make the back row selections a little easier, with Beattie and Brown inked in and a straight shootout between Denton and Strokosch for the remaining berth at 6. At least you hope it is at 6.

You could argue it is lunacy not to have a proper fetcher in the team, but with Fusaro and Rennie’s fitness uncertain it seems in this instance, once again, Scotland have little choice.

6 Responses

  1. There’s too much negativity around this appointment which is primarily a PR f***-up.

    Scott Johnson led Scotland to our best 6N finish in years and we should be confident that the squad should continue to progress for the next year he is potentially in charge for. The 2 years Cotter plans to manage Scotland for could be 2 years that transforms the individuals in our young squad into confident, international class test players. This could benefit Scotland for years to come.

    He might not have time to prepare properly for the world cup. Who cares? I would happily bow out at the group stages again if we won a 6N title in return. We should focus on being competitive at every 6N before worrying about the world cup cycle. If we do this, world cup performances will look after themselves.

    I’m glad we have a world class coach on his way to Scotland even if we have to wait for a year. I just hope that Johnson puts in place adequate pathways for Scottish coaches to come through so that we are not at the mercy of the international market place to get in a coach to match our ambitions in the future. The pro-team head coaches need to be Scottish, and the national team’s assistants too, if we are to develop Scottish coaches with the skills and knowledge to do the top-job. Hopefully, Cotter will hang around long enough to pass the baton to Townshend (after he wins the Heineken Cup or whatever replaces it).

  2. Totally agree with FF…far too much negativity. Great appointment. I often wonder who the Scottish rugby media/fans want? If Graham Hendry took the job presumably someone would call him a has been,,,,

  3. Too much is being made of Scotland’s placing in the 6 nations. Coming third on points difference after only two victories over an injury ravaged and inexperienced Ireland at home as well as Italy does not herald a new era.

    1. The last time we won 2 games in the 6 Nations was 2006. 2 victories is nigh on a bloody miracle!

      It is a real improvement, no one is heralding a new era but we shouldn’t pretend we are in a place where 2 victories in the 6N is not a degree of success which must be built on.

  4. Looks like his bosses called his bluff, or whatever was going on. We won’t see Vern till June then!

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion