Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


The Late Night Lion Panic

Lions 2013

Everyone’s favourite fantasy rugby exercise, The British and Irish Lions, kicks off in a major way tomorrow when coach Warren Gatland announces his squad. Fittingly, here at the Scottish Rugby Blog we are bringing up the rear in style.

I’m on record as loving the Quixotic nature of the Lions, and although it is now a fearsomely commercial beast, the Lions enterprise is still at it’s heart a very pure form of sport. That is probably why we all enjoy it so much. But it can also be hugely frustrating, especially when one of our favourites is overlooked.

The mild fillip of the Six Nations has raised Scottish hopes that perhaps some of our guys can mix it with the big boys, but there is plenty of chatter – the sort of chatter all non-Welsh lions fans worry about – about record-breaking amounts of Welsh players in the squad, about Irish players outnumbering their Scottish and English conquerors.


I can’t predict it, no-one can. But here are a few thoughts.

The Front-Row Union

Ryan Grant played Adam Jones off the park two weeks ago almost everywhere except the scrums (that was a stalemate) and is peaking at precisely the right moment. Healy and Jenkins are his main rivals and neither have covered themselves in glory but are seen as the safe choices. If Grant does not at least get a shot to tour it would be a travesty; with Euan Murray’s glory pretty faded these days it would be likely Grant is the only serious contender. Ross Ford and Geoff Cross had a few mentions late in the Six Nations but their chances faded the second the sign above the Murrayfield changing room switched back from “Scotland” to “Edinburgh”.

The Boilerhouse

Paul O’Connell is back from rugby limbo and alongside Alun Wyn Jones and the odd English lock, Richie Gray’s chances have long been talked up. If they only took say 4 second rows, then suddenly Gray could well be a surprise cut from everyone’s list of definite tourists. He didn’t do enough in the Six Nations, then he got injured. If O’Connell didn’t reappear then he was a cert. Now, I’m not so sure. Taking him could even be a risk, though I have no doubt he has the potential to thrive. Kellock, Hines and Hamilton will all have been considered at some point but may have drifted off radar. Hines could still make a surprise venture if he can get out of France alive, for a second time.

The $64,000 Question

The captain is widely assumed to be Sam Warburton, but whether or not that sets off a chain reaction of back-row selection shuffles that results in Chris Robshaw and/or Kelly Brown being popped off the back of the bus and left at home remains to be seen. The issue is who to take, with about 4-5 very good players on both flanks, and enough versatility amongst them to ensure that they could also clog up the Number 8 selection worries where there is less choice (Faletau, Johnnie Beattie, Heaslip). If I was Gatland, the back row would be the one causing me headaches at tonight’s final selection meeting.

Spare also a thought for Ross Rennie, who was well on his way to be a big part of this debate before a big injury killed his momentum.

The Old (and Young) Guys in Midfield

AKA Jonny Wilkinson and Brian O’Driscoll, O’Driscoll is a highly likely candidate given the dearth of world-class centres and could earn a glorious swansong if he could repeat 2009’s stellar partnership with Jamie Roberts. Wilkinson refuses to retire but has still been imperious for Toulon. He’s right though in suggesting Gatland looks to the future. Unfortunately that means that the furiously talented James Hook will also probably be overlooked as Gatland has never quite found a use for him. Matt Scott could be one for the future, but as 10-13 has long been Scotland’s problem area I don’t need to tell you we won’t see any Lions there this time out, unless Greig Laidlaw is brought to cover 10 as well as 9 – a possibility. If he does go we can only hope he has a better tour than Mike Blair four years ago.

The Back Three

I’ve already talked up Stuart Hogg’s chances over on MSN, and while the bookies put Tim Visser on the plane for his scoring weight of numbers, Sean Maitland now strikes me as the more useful tourist. Useful across a number of positions, serious gas, familiar with the Aussies – he once scored four against the Brumbies and is Quade Cooper’s cousin – and good in defence. Gatland will want form guys, and of those two Maitland has that and is playing at a higher intensity level. Whether anyone gets a look past Gatland’s Welsh back three on tour is anyone’s guess. They’ll have to earn it.

Who then from Scotland could be on the plane tomorrow, and who will not?

I think Grant, Hogg, and Maitland will go. I think Laidlaw and Gray might, and I think Brown will miss out despite offering excellent credentials. Hogg is the only one I am truly sure of, but only Warren Gatland and his cabal truly know.

The rest of us wait for the sleepless night to pass that we may be enlightened, frustrated or delightedcome 11am tomorrow.

11 Responses

  1. Ryan Grant should be on the plane, don’t think Euan Murray should have even been considered.
    I would like Richie Gray to go but it wouldn’t surprise me if he was left out, since joining Sale he hasn’t shown much form, if he had stayed at Glasgow there would be no doubt he would be in the starting XV.
    Matt Scott, in my opinion hasn’t done enough in the Scotland shirt yet so I feel Gatland will over look him. But I can see him in a future Lions team for sure.
    I also think Laidlaw might miss out, even though he does provide a 9/10 cover, is he actually good enough to play either of these positions at Lions level? Debatable.
    Hogg should go, although I would love him to start, I think he will be on the bench as Gatland won’t can see past Halfpenny and I wouldn’t play Halfpenny anywhere else but fullback due to his attacking skills being non existent.
    Maitland should go ahead of the likes of Zebo and Visser, he is a great all round performer and in good form for Glasgow. The fact he can cover other positions is just a bonus.
    And I am gutted to say I think Kelly Brown will miss out. That guy is unbelievable but Gatland won’t can see past Warbuton, Tipuric and Falataeu.
    So I think we will probably get 3 on the plane although I would love to see more!

  2. after all that,…we get 3…………… fair play to Maitland like,…Hogg always had to go,… and from day 1 Gray has been a lion in waiting,.. dip in form aside, but Vunipola, Hartley, Hibbard, Jenkins clearly not required by Toulon to get to go. O’Brien is a one trick pony (smash going forward but on the back foot?)and Heaslip…granted has the pedigree but poor 6 nations. Lydiate has 2 full games and 2 halves,coming back from injury. Reputations being taken for a lot by Gatland.
    No Hook, Brown,Launchbury, Twelvetrees or even Laidlaw. Ah well…

  3. Can’t for the life of me see the point in bringing 3 FBs and only 2 FHs when Maitland can cover FB but no-one else int he squad can cover FH. Very odd.

    Also, I hope Hogg gets the opportunity to push his case for the test side as the Lions probable back line is seriously short of some magic. Would be great to see Maitland get to run with the ball more often as he never gets it with Scotland!

  4. Apparently Hoggs “x-factor” extends to his ability to cover 13 and 10 at a push… maybe he’s the 10 cover if someone were to go down in a game, HIGHLY UNLIKELY but food for thought

  5. Well done ASWarrior totally called it right , unfortunately, thought we might have got another three on the plane but hey ho I suppose the squad was always going to be top heavy with Welsh players given Gatlands track record. Ryan Grant especially should count himself unlucky. The Welsh have always been bad tourers so we shall see what happens to the team dynamic when push comes to shove.

  6. No Ryan Grant = total joke.

    Too many people selected on past glories and reputation, disappointed but not suprised.

  7. Disappointed that Ryan Grant never made it, hoping he is the reserve if a prop gets injured. He should be there in front of Stevens, Vunipola and Cole in my opinion.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion