Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Deja Vu As Edinburgh Go House-Hunting

Murrayfield Stadium - © Scottish Rugby Blog
Murrayfield Stadium pic © Scottish Rugby Blog

Edinburgh followers have been here before, but the reporting of tentative discussions between the SRU and Edinburgh City Council on the occupation of a restored Meadowbank can only be greeted with anticipation.

Finding a suitable home for Edinburgh has been long overdue. Before settling at Murrayfield, Edinburgh’s peripatetic approach had seen games played throughout the capital, at Easter Road, Myreside, and Meadowbank, with moves to Sighthill, or an expanded Tynecastle also mooted at times. Such a track record is suggestive of a leadership unable to grasp the need to put down roots. A stadium is part of the brand, and an appropriate move for the team would be a statement of intent and an opportunity to build bridges with sports fans in the East.

That a new home is needed is plain. Murrayfield is far too big, and playing at the National Stadium undermines the individual identity of Edinburgh Rugby. Recent European games demonstrate that there has always been a serviceable appetite for pro rugby in the city, with supporters laying down a marker when Toulouse came to town, however it is also likely that many people turned up then because they knew they were guaranteed a good atmosphere. To grow as quickly as they should, Edinburgh need a smaller, more intimate venue that will allow an pulsating atmosphere to be regularly reproduced, and expected, at every home game.

Where that would be is now the question. All stadiums already mentioned are unsuitable in their current condition; Easter road and Tynecastle are arguably too big, with congested fixture lists, Myreside is too small. Meadowbank is dilapidated; however, this allows a rare opportunity to tailor any redesign to Edinburgh’s requirements.

With only one stand and a running track separating the stand from the pitch (and a general 1970s vibe) Meadowbank is not satisfactorily prepared. Potential is there, however, being not too far from pubs in Abbeyhill and adjacent to main roads. For Meadowbank to become suitable, it would need investment in hospitality and parking, a couple of new stands, and an overall capacity of around 10,000, reflecting current potential Demand for professional rugby. This should not be out of the question.

That the ground is central is also a plus point. Welsh clubs and Cardiff in particular have experienced declining crowd numbers, coinciding with a move from their traditional homes to impressively built out-of-town locations. It seems notable that the Dragons are opting to redevelop their existing ground at Rodney Parade. The three powerhouse Irish provinces have also committed to city centre locations, recognising that if the ground is relatively inaccessible, the club is too.

It is also important to get the funding right, something that Scottish Rugby has not always done – that central funds were not applied for during the redevelopment of Murrayfield in the mid-1990s is often highlighted as a big mistake. The most impressive venues in France have large council input, whilst the Department of Sport in Northern Ireland has recently invested £14.7 million in a new Ravenhill. This is enlightened, and recognises the role that rugby plays in the community and also the positive Economic benefits that an attractive, well-funded team may generate. Any new stadium should come with council backing.

That a well-known supermarket may be involved in the talks is not necessarily a bad thing, though. Most fans would prioritise above all a club that invests in the future. As long as there is a clear and credible stadium-plan that fits into the growth strategy of the club as a whole, it is unlikely that anyone will get too precious about naming rights, or land deals with private investors.

Other teams have made their moves a great success, moves which mostly came about due to perceived increased demand; Leinster’s crowd has grown from 3900 during the first Celtic League season to 12,500 season ticket holders alone today. This advancement was built around team success, retention of internationalists, good youth programmes, but also a stable structure. In 2007 Leinster signed a 20 year lease at the RDS, signalling commitment.

Many are tempted to dismiss stadium plans by saying that anything that happens will only occur two to three years down the line, but thinking from a long term point of view is essential for building success on the pitch. If Edinburgh Rugby is to be a serious proposition, then a move to something the fans can build into an intimidating fortress is needed. Everyone knows that Murrayfield is only a contingency venue – but could be a handy backup for big European games – and that the team and the fans need to occupy somewhere else they can call home.

Only once a decision is made can Edinburgh continue to maximise the momentum off the pitch that the team are building on it.

Article by Andrew Armstrong

7 Responses

  1. Meadowbank seems the most likely home. Properly renovated it seems to tick all the boxes, except one. We drive through from St Andrews. On a friday night after finishing work after 5.00pm the extra 20 minutes each way would make it an occasional trip rather than a season ticket. What is parking like? I seem to remember a match in trevious residence where it wasn’t straight forward
    There were rumours of a greenfield site out towards the airport. FRom a purely selfish point of view this would be ideal.

    1. Meadowbank is a poor choice, It’s too far away from the railway station and general facilities around the stadium are poor also, Saturday games would be an issue if there was a match at Easter Road, the area would be total gridlock. The ground itself is dilapidated, it would need as much money thrown at it to bring the facilities to a decent standard for Pro games as developing one of the grounds closer to both the city centre and the transport links, EG Inverleith, Goldenacre or Raeburn Place, alternatively a small development on the back pitches would surely be an option…

  2. Totally agree Rory. Cardiff’s move back to CAF and Saracens finally getting planning to set up a permanent home are symptomatic of the need and want of clubs to settle down. Meadowbank is the prime candidate, and having moved to the east coast 4 months ago, I now pass it every day on the bus! Could I possibly leave my Warriors supporter status for Edinburgh? Unlikely, but Meadowbank would be a great opportunity to create a very good venue for Edinburgh rugby and the city.

  3. I should point out chaps that this piece was written by Andrew who is new here! Forgot to add in the credit… I didn’t write Colin Gregor’s diary either. Brain-freeze…

    I think the new venue has to be central. Cardiff are dying on the outskirts, fans and even the players want to play at the Arms Park and aren’t afraid to come out and say it. Being able to walk/bus to the stadium should be key for building the core of a committed Friday night support.

  4. This is probably a very unrealistic idea, but what if Edinburgh Rugby were to play in Princess St Gardens! Obviously there would have to be a lot of work done to build such a ground, but the location would be supreme. We are missing a trick here in that Edinburgh has a booming tourism industry. Imagine how spectacular the setting would be!

  5. Also, what about a 10,000 seater in the Meadows? People would flock from within the city centre and attendance would go right up. I always thought Godenacre would have been a great Edinburgh ground as well. There is enough room to build another stand and it’s in a really good location with great history for Edinburgh’s rugby.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards
Craig is joined by John on the injured reserve list to have a wee look at the URC action from the weekend.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion