Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Filling Out The Corners

Tomorrow Andy Robinson will announce his extended training squad for this year’s Six Nations (starting a month from now with a match against England), and as Alan pointed out in his earlier piece there are very few players guaranteed a spot in the starting team, so picking a captain will be hard.

What about the fringe players making a claim for a spot – who might get the call up?

This will likely be an expanded squad of around 35 (last year’s was 34) and initial meetings will be more about confirming an ethos and team-bonding to make sure everyone is pointing the same way – even if a bunch of them then get shunted back to their clubs.

A few faces will be absent from the 30 he took to New Zealand – Nathan Hines and Chris Paterson have retired. Without them, the last squad would look like this:

Backs: (12/16)
Simon Danielli , Max Evans, Rory Lamont, Sean Lamont.
Joe Ansbro, Nick De Luca, Graeme Morrison.
Fly-halves: Ruaridh Jackson, Dan Parks.
Scrum-halves: Mike Blair, Chris Cusiter, Rory Lawson.

Forwards: (16/18)
Geoff Cross, Alasdair Dickinson, Allan Jacobsen, Moray Low, Euan Murray.
Ross Ford, Dougie Hall, Scott Lawson.
Locks: Richie Gray, Jim Hamilton, Alastair Kellock.
John Barclay, Kelly Brown, Ross Rennie, Alasdair Strokosch, Richie Vernon.

So who might get added to the mix – or even removed? (assuming another 6 places up for grabs to get up to 2011 squad size, the second figure in brackets above)


It would be tempting to add both Weir and Laidlaw in, and they are almost certain to get a training call-up given their form – Laidlaw got the call in 2011 for an injured Cusiter. But if you also ditch Parks as I am sure some of you are thinking, that makes Laidlaw the best kicker in the squad, but unlikely to start at either 9 or 10. Whether Robinson is willing to risk Laidlaw at 10 is also questionable, although I would like nothing more than to see him thrown in there. It is as far out from a World Cup as you can get, and if there is ever a time to blood some young talent with half an eye on the future then this is it. Although I am sure Stephen Jones would disagree, given his love of test match “animals”.

With no Mossy and no Nikki Walker, we could also use another wing. Visser will be the obvious choice come June but for now Lee Jones might just sneak in, ahead of say Jack Cuthbert or Colin Shaw.

I’m not convinced Hogg is quite ready for the step up although he has been great in patches, but I think his versatility will help him here – a centre cum fullback could be useful in the squad environment but might hurt him come selection time. After the World Cup you could easily argue De Luca should be dropped but his form since that ill-fated tournament has been nothing short of brilliant and I’d like to see him and Ansbro (who has been scoring tries for London Irish) starting, however crazy that sounds. I also think we might see the return of an old favourite (sorry Dave) in the form of Wasps’ fullback Hugo Southwell.

Add-ins: (4)
Greig Laidlaw (for Mike Blair), Duncan Weir, Stuart Hogg, Hugo Southwell, Lee Jones


The key spot here is most likely the fourth second row berth. Based on form, it looks like Fraser McKenzie should get the nod ahead of Grant Gilchrist. With the top front row performers now pretty much clear cut (Chunk, Ford and either Murray or Cross), it’s the backup slots up for grabs. Last year Jon Welsh got in as Dickinson was injured, and again it’s probably the diminutive prop now playing at Sale who could be under threat.

It is also possible some of our favourites such as Vernon or the Big Stroker might get shunted in favour of a young tyro such as David Denton or Rob Harley, both of whom have done enough this season to merit a place. Johnnie Beattie is also back in the mix now too, having shown a bit of form of late.

Add-ins: (2)
Fraser McKenzie, David Denton, Johnnie Beattie (for Vernon)

If I could have an extra slot to make it 35 I’d keep Vernon. So, you know, we get more tour diaries.

Pretty simple eh? Who would you take as your 4 extra backs and 2 extra forwards? If you want to shift the balance a bit, up to you! Let us know in the comments.

We’ll see what Andy Robinson has to say tomorrow.

Support N50 Sports

8 Responses

  1. Backs

    Jones (for Walker), Laidlaw (for Blair), Weir (for Parks), King and Hogg.


    MacKenzie, Welsh (for Dickinson), Denton and Harley (for Vernon). No room for Beattie I’m afraid – Denton can cover 8 and Harley deserves a reward for his consistent excellence. Beattie needs a good run of form, not just the odd game.

  2. Agree with MJW about the backs but I would put in Ryan Grant (if fit) instead of Welsh & I think Beattie should be in the squad, don’t know who I’d take out to make space for him though

  3. Backs: (16)
    Full-backs:Rory Lamont, Hugo Southwell
    Wings: Simon Danielli , Max Evans,Lee Jones, Sean Lamont.
    Centres: Joe Ansbro, Nick De Luca, Graeme Morrison,Stuart Hogg
    Fly-halves: Ruaridh Jackson, Dan Parks.Duncan Weir,
    Scrum-halves: Mike Blair Chris Cusiter (CAPT) Greig Laidlaw.

    Forwards: (19)
    Props: Geoff Cross, Alasdair Dickinson, Allan Jacobsen, Moray Low, Euan Murray.
    Hookers: Ross Ford, Dougie Hall, Scott Lawson.
    Locks: Richie Gray, Jim Hamilton, Alastair Kellock.Fraser McKenzie
    Flankers: John Barclay, Kelly Brown, Ross Rennie, Alasdair Strokosch, Rob Harley
    No 8: Dave Denton, Johnie Beattie

  4. I’ll put down my squad

    Backs (16)
    Full-backs: Rory Lamont, Hugo Southwell (apparently he’s been playing well for Wasps)
    Wings: Max Evans, Sean Lamont, Lee Jones (needs to work on his defence), Colin Shaw/Simon Danielli (apparently Danielli has been dropped from the Ulster squad & Shaw has been playing well for Glasgow so it’s a toss up between the two)
    Centres: Joe Ansbro, Nick De Luca, Graeme Morrison, Stuart Hogg
    Fly-halves: Ruaridh Jackson, Duncan Weir, Dan Parks
    Scrum-halves: Greig Laidlaw, Chris Cusiter (CAPT), Rory Lawson

    Forwards: (19)
    Props: Geoff Cross, Ryan Grant (if fit, if not then Jon Welsh), Allan Jacobsen, Moray Low, Euan Murray
    Hookers: Ross Ford, Dougie Hall, Scott Lawson/Pat MacArthur (don’t know how Lawson has been playing & MacArthur is doing really well this season)
    Locks: Richie Gray, Jim Hamilton, Alastair Kellock, Fraser McKenzie
    Flankers: John Barclay, Kelly Brown, Ross Rennie, Alasdair Strokosch, Rob Harley
    No 8: Dave Denton, Johnie Beattie

  5. The squad will be there or there abouts with most of the players listed (a journalist I spoke to the other day reckons the number of players involved will initially be near 40). However I can only add to this discussion players who I think should slip out if there is ample replacement options: Dougie Hall, Hugo Southwell and Colin Shaw should not be considered in order to allow younger guys to come in and because they are no better than those younger options anymore. Beattie has not played enough to merit selection and Danielli…well… I cannot think of a reason, but I’d rather see Jones in. He will be there, though, won’t he?

  6. Danielli? AR shouldn’t pick him if he isn’t playing regularly (and playing well) for Ulster. A few Ulster fans that I know tell me that he isn’t exactly setting the heather alight over there.

    Lee Jones is in fine form at Edinburgh, so if it’s a toss up between the two I’d have Jones in everyday of the week.

    According to the Scotsman (your journalist, Alan?), there may be quite a few fresh faces, including Gilchrist, McInally (in place of Beattie) and MacArthur.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion