Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


I Was Monty’s Double

Glasgow announced earlier in the week that Sean Lamont is to join his brother Rory at the Warriors from next season, following a successful spell at Welsh region the Scarlets where he has played not only wing, but also centre and fullback. Indeed this year’s Six Nations went on to see Sean collect unexpected international honours in the centre, filling in for Graeme Morrison during the Six Nations where he proved an effective battering ram.

It continues a concerted push by the SRU in recent months to strengthen the Glasgow team in the eyes of not just the public but perhaps their own players, to prevent anyone else around Scotstoun from thinking a move to Manchester is an upgrade.

This means that with the recovery from surgery of DTH Van Der Merwe – who was last year almost pushing for the title of Scotland’s Most Effective Winger With a Dutch Name – the Warriors would next season boast a back division laden with international experience – and dare we whisper it – strength in depth on the bench too. David Lemi was brought in as cover on a short term contract but it might be safe to assume that next season he will be surplus to requirements. Even without the Samoan flyer (who it is hoped will get a chance to show what he can do in the spring), Glasgow could have a back three of both Lamonts and DTHVDM, with Morrison and AN Other in the centre and Jackson, Weir and Wight scuffling over the 10 shirt. Although getting on a bit, Federico Aramburu and Troy Nathan have also been solid performers this season and Tommy Seymour will be hoping he gets a chance on the wing too.

All that is before you take into account the youth who were blooded while the World Cup was on, and who many believe are the real reason for this mini-renaissance. Fullback Stuart Hogg has already shown enough to suggest that while this year may be a little early for international honours, he is going to be fighting Rory Lamont tooth and nail for that Glasgow and possibly Scotland 15 shirt in years to come. Alex Dunbar and Peter Murchie have had pro-team appearances for Glasgow and there are also talents like Peter Horne away gaining Sevens experience but who must be planning to slip back into the 15s game eventually, possibly at his U20 position of fullback.

So how do you fit them all in? After all, the reason there is a buzz around the pro-teams at the moment is that the youngsters (on both coasts) have been learning to win and lose on their own two (or thirty) feet and the seasoned internationals have not just been waltzing back into their slots. This result of this buzz has attracted the Lamonts home, but might the perceived ease with which to claim a starting berth and put themselves under Andy Robinson’s microscope have been an attraction too? Now they get here they find that is no longer the case and Lineen will have to find a delicate balance between keeping his big signings happy and bringing on the new blood – that which we have all called for in order to see the teams progress.

The prime example of this dilemma – other than Hogg v Lamont – is Jackson and Weir, who have resumed the battle for the 10 shirt with no clear front runner since the World Cup. They have drifted in and out of form, and each has managed to look good coming off the bench while not being entirely convincing from the start.

Is it better to have two equally talented players helping their pro-team to victory in rotated shifts, or to have one playing week in week out and primed for the step up to international duty – while the other stagnates? Certainly youngsters with experience, confidence and form are more useful on the bench than those without as has been seen in the past. The extra chances afforded by the World Cup may just be the best thing that happens to this generation of Scottish players.

One option could be to shuffle some of the talent around a bit. It happens often enough in the front row – Ryan Grant has now played for both pro-teams, and the defunct Borders. Rob Dewey has not really settled in since his return from Ulster, and it might be possible that he would consider a return to the stomping grounds at Murrayfield where he made his name. Especially as Edinburgh have plenty of ball-playing centres but no real battering rams as Robinson seems to like. Young Hogg is not yet snapped up to a pro contract at Glasgow despite plaudits for recent performances (at least up until his slightly nervy performance on Saturday, apparently put down to concussion) and might even be a candidate for Edinburgh.

The capital team have 2 solid first choice wings in Visser and Jones but their immediate replacements are not clear, nor have Edinburgh settled on a long term replacement for Chris Paterson who announced his international retirement yesterday. The demand for true competition to fill his international shirt may end up with him eased out at club level too, although you feel someone as level headed and passionate about the game as he is will not be away for long. Edinburgh of course have Tom Brown and Jim Thompson waiting in the wings at fullback, but on the international stage Rory Lamont is probably the best fit even if Hugo Southwell’s current form at Wasps is great.

Which, of course, means Lamont needs game time at Glasgow; full circle. Hogg might be the man, but if Lamont is the man then he needs to play. So how do you find out if Hogg might be the man in future?

All in all though, whether you are Michael Bradley, Sean Lineen or indeed Andy Robinson, it’s not a bad problem to have at last.

Support N50 Sports

5 Responses

  1. I’m torn on the Glasgow full back conundrum. On the one hand I would really like to see Hogg get plenty of game time so he can develop into a test 15. On the other hand I really do not want to see Southwell play for Scotland again so this probably means that R Lamont needs to play there for his club.

    For me the fact that Southwell might be playing well for Wasps is not the point. At this stage of the season every year Scotland fans have this discussion about his good form for his club, which then leads to yet another recall, a string of poor performances and him being dropped once more. People also keep going on about his great left boot but really he catches the odd one and the rest of the time his kicking from hand is pretty poor. He is an ok player at club level but after 59 caps I think it is pretty obvious that he never has and never will cut it at test level. Personally I would pick R Lamont, Hogg, Jim Thompson and Cuthbert ahead of him.

  2. It’s good to see the Glasgow squad being strengthened but what they really need to do is sort out who is going to play 13 next year. They have plenty of centres on their books but no out and out 13s. Morrison, Nathan, Dewey, Dunbar, Murchie and Horne are all 12s essentially. Personally I think they should offload Dewey at the end of this season and sign a quality outside centre and that young guy Robbie Fergusson (who can also play 10) to cover 13. I think they should then allow Morrison to move on at the end of next season when his contract runs out. It’s time to give some younger like Dunbar and Horne a chance at 12 as we really need to unearth some good young inside centres. I am hoping Matt Scott might be the long-term answer at 12 for Scotland but it would be good to build some strength in depth there.

    Maybe Lineen is thinking of using DTHVDM at 13 next season and there has been talk about Hogg playing there as well. I don’t think S Lamont is the answer. I would prefer to see Hogg developed at 15 because I reckon there is less strength in depth there at international level. Either way, Lineen needs to get a proper 13 playing there if he wants some more creativity and cutting edge in the backs. Depending on how Lemi gets on this season there could be scope to keep him in the squad. You could have R Lamont and Hogg fighting it out for the 15 shirt and S Lamont, Lemi, DTH and Seymour competing for the wing slots. If DTH is going to be used as a centre then there is definitely scope to keep Lemi, unless Lineen thinks that any of the young wingers in the EDP are ready to step up which there are no signs of as yet.

  3. In terms of centres, you probably want to think about how the Scotland team works – Robbo seems to favour a direct bruiser at 12 (Dewey, Lamont, Morrison) with the hands outside. So from that point of view Nathan or Horne could work at 13. Of course, you might prefer a bit more from your centres say a D’Arcy/BOD style pairing in which case Lineen as you say may need to go looking….

  4. Yep Robinson does seem to prefer crash ballers at 12 but I wonder if that’s really because he has had no choice. Since he took over Morrison has been the only real choice at 12 until he moved Lamont there. De Luca can play 12 but quite rightly Robinson sees him as a 13. Similarly Grove who he gave one game at 12 I think. I reckon he should give King a go in the 6Ns to try and find some more creativity in the back line but I assume he thinks he is too small.

    Personally I think Nathan and Horne are more suited to 12. Both are decent ball players who can kick and I’m not sure if either of them have the pace to be really effective outside centres. Either way I think it is time to develop some more options at 12 rather than one-dimensional bashers like Morrison and Dewey.

    As I said hopefully Matt Scott will be the long-term solution at 12 for Scotland. Looks a very versatile player to me. Big enough to do the crash ball job but a good all round ball player as well.

    Agree that Horne’s best position might be 15. So frustrating that there are only to pro teams to develop these players.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Rory and Iain to look at the latest news including Scotland's win over Canada and the upcoming test against the USA.
Gregor Townsend has picked the strongest XV possible from his touring squad for the visit to Washington DC to play the USA, writes Rory.
Gregor Townsend has named his team to face Canada in the first match of the Skyscanner Americas Tour with 10 players given the opportunity to make their Scotland debut.
Craig is joined by Iain, Jonny and Rory to discuss Glasgow's momentous win in the final of the 2024 URC

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion