Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


A Weak End for Bernie?

After four successful years of over achieving, Bernardo Stortoni fast became a favourite with the Firhill faithful. But now it looks like it’s on to pastures new for the 34-year-old.

So who will fill his ankle length socks now? Who will be the master of the high ball? Who will make up for defensive frailties of Glasgow’s standoffs? Will somebody step up to enter the hearts of the Firhill faithful at fifteen in his absence?

Glasgow, at present, have a number of options:

Colin Gregor – The Glasgow Warriors man has been a jack of all trades and a master of none for the Firhill side He has played full back before and his kicking and ability to break is not in question. Opportunities at scrum half will be limited next season with the return of Chris Cusiter and the continued improvement of Henry Pyrgos. However, his defensive frailties might resign Budgie to perennial nearly man status for the Warriors.

Peter Horne – He has never taken the opportunities offered to him by Lineen (especially a nightmare he will want to forget against Llanelli) but he is still very young and the Warriors coaching staff may have seen something in him in training to offer him an opportunity to make the jersey his own.

Peter Murchie – A big presence who has also been deployed at centre, Murchie would add even more powerful running to the Glasgow back three. On signing the youngster from Bath, Lineen enthused: “He has the raw material we can shape into a special player”. Maybe this is his time?

Stuart Hogg – Captain of the Scotland under 18 team, mostly a stand-off Mr Hogg will see opportunities few and far between at 10 while Weir and Jackson continue to wrestle for the position. Could Stortoni’s departure open up a chance to impress for the Elite development player?

Colin Shaw – Almost the forgotten man, a lot of potential that seems to have near fizzled out. Has looked impressive on the wing but more unsure at full back. Also, from the stands at Firhill it appears as if he has had problems with his fitness and concentration. But at 27, it’s not too late.

So what other options are out there? Of course there is a whole world full of rough diamonds that Lineen and his team have unearthed in the past, but being a Scottish rugby blog, we will look at the Scottish possibilities.

It makes sense for the SRU to have all their players under roof in Central Scotland at either Glasgow or Edinburgh, they can make sure that internationals have adequate playing time. Then, a player like Joe Ansbro, who is undoubtedly capable, would be assured not to languish with few opportunities on the Northampton subs bench (or London Irish – ed.)

The exiles:

Rory Lamont – Having lost his place in the Scotland squad to the reliable Hugo Southwell, and no longer a young buck, Lamont may look to a return to Glasgow to force his way back into the Scotland team. He would provide more of an attacking threat than Stortoni and a chance to form a link with a number of present Scotland international backs may be an appealing option. It may become difficult for Rory to keep his head above the water while moneybags in France continue to spend.

Hugo Southwell – Would fit right into the safe pair of hands role vacated by Stortoni and would be a veteran in a Glasgow team set to be more and more focussed on youth. However, would he leave the glamour of Stade Francais for the Warriors?

Jack Cuthbert – Huge man, huge boot, huge talent – if given the chance he could be a very talented player for Scotland. He has, however, been keeping Nick Abdenanon out of the Bath team, so it is unlikely he would leave what he has at Bath for Glasgow.

However, to get a player even of Lamont, Cuthbert or Southwell’s stature, Glasgow would need something that they don’t have – money.

It feels like there was a time when a player like Euan Murray became available (international, British & Irish Lion, Scottish legend, career on the downward slope but would still do a great job) Glasgow or Edinburgh would have snapped him up, but that is no longer the case.

In that context, now even players like Lamont and Southwell seem almost pie in the sky.

At 34-years-old, it’s probably the right time for Stortoni to go, however, he will be missed greatly. What he provided was continuity throughout the times that Scotland were on international duty. While other leaders were away playing for their country, he could provide a sense of continuity.

If Glasgow do decide/are forced to go young at full back, that combined with an inexperienced stand off could be a dangerous mix. The Argentinian was an insurance policy for the failings of Dan Parks and he often acts as one for Ruaridh Jackson, this could be the Glasgow Warriors putting more faith in Jackson to step up as a leader or having no other choice.

But that can’t be guaranteed, so what about one more insurance policy?

Chris Paterson: Experienced, already under the employ of the SRU. It would serve in the SRU’s best interests to have an ageing but experienced head such as Paterson serving as a mentor, and an insurance policy to the youth of Murchie, Horne or Hogg at full back, as well as Jackson and Weir at stand off.

So, Glasgow Warriors fans, what is your answer to filling the hole left by Stortoni?

Support N50 Sports

4 Responses

  1. Of course the other option which has not been put forth above is to move Jackson to 15, leaving Weir as the 1st choice no. 10. This would allow us to bring in a promising understudy for Weir. There are a number of Glasgow fans who think Jacko might make a better full back than stand off. However, I don’t see this happening.

    What we must not do is mess about with Murchie and Horne. Muchie is showing some promise at 12, and while with Morrison signing for another two years he is unlikely to be in pole position, the fact that Morrison is likely to miss September (as he’ll be at the World Cup) means that Murchie is still guaranteed a decent amount of time at 12.

    Horne has looked liveliest at 13, and that’s where I’d like to see him developed. Don’t mess around and create a mediocre player who is a jack of all trades but master of none. Make a decision on what his best position is and develop him.

    When Bernie went off on Friday against Cardiff, it was Murchie who dropped back to 15, not Horne. So I don’t know if that indicated anything about the way SL is thinking.

    Don’t particularly warm to the idea of Southwell or Paterson. Both are the wrong side of 30, and I could not see Paterson swap East for West. I guess Lamont’s position is dependant on if he see’s himself being able to hold onto a 1st team place at Toulon. I’d be happier with Lamont than Southwell or Paterson ..although I’d worry slightly at how often he get’s injured. Glasgow has enough players who seem to be injured more often than they are fit, without adding to this number. Cuthbert is a different proposition, young with a good future ahead of him, and would also be a moral boost to the fans after loosing big name players (i.e. Parks, Brown, Max and Thom Evans).

    The other rumour that has done the rounds is that Jim Thompson will move West to Glasgow and therefore get regular game time at 15.

  2. Not convinced with Horne at all. I also think that we DO need players who can play in more than 1 position and do this well. Look at Hook..15, 12, 10. Wilkinson 10, 12. Jones 10,12. Giteau etc etc. Jackson, Parks, Weir can only play 10. Morrison 12.We really need to get more rugby players through whatever system we use!
    Now as for emerging talent…Tam Broon?

  3. I’ve been pretty impressed with Horne the few times I have seen him playing (mostly age grade a year or two back) but that was attacking from 15, never really thought of him as a centre. But I do remember that stinker he had against Llanelli. Colin Gregor had a few games at FB, I thought he looked good but he may be a bit wee – still so is Ben Foden and it hasn’t hurt him much.

  4. Colin Gregor in my opinion has two obvious weaknesses – both of which could be worked on so they are not so. (1) His pass from the bottom of a ruck or scrum is neither long enough or accurate enough so him to be a top class scrum half. It has in general improved over the season, but too often his pass is either a hospital pass (trying to hard to get distance at the loss of accuracy) or down at the 10’s toes (neither distance or accuracy). Nevertheless, his vision for wee snipping breaks is great. (2) His defence is not great. Tends to be to up-right in my opinion and that bigger guys just run right over him.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion