Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Rank Outsiders

Sooooo…….. Anyone watch the boxing on Saturday night? Anyone wash their car on Saturday afternoon? Walk their dog? Build a shed? Listen to your other half’s problems? Play tig with the busses? Ok, that last one was probably after you watched the rugby…

Black Saturday, as it will forever be known, is over. Forgotten. That’s the good news. The bad news? The world champion Bokke are headed into town as we speak.

They’ve been humiliated in the tri-nations, Peter De Villiers is the rugby equivalent of Boris Johnson and there are rumours that they were collectively drinking themselves into oblivion the week before their Autumn tour (drinking Irn-Bru? – ed.) Yet they have won twice! It hasn’t been pretty, but they’ve seen off Wales and Ireland. The gate to Murrayfield is swinging open…

We have come a long way under Robbo, but Saturday shows us just how far we have still to go.

In drawing with England, toppling Ireland and beating Argentina twice we moved up to 7th in the IRB rankings. However, this could have been seen as a false economy.

We played England at their own game and, in their transitional phase, they almost rolled over under the full brunt of 5 million people. Almost.

Ireland were bullied, and Scotland played the best they have probably played in five years. That is fair enough.

Argentina are an ageing team, some would argue a spent force, and their untested players are, well, untested. We beat them twice and leapfrogged them in the rankings. They’ve just taken 7th spot back, and we’ve dropped to 8, again. To be fair this shouldn’t last for long as we both play the same way (a pivot at 10 who creates pressure with kicking, and forwards who are abrasive in defence and offload in attack) but we are slightly better at it.

We can even work up to 6th during the 6N. Ireland are slipping backwards and the pressure on an also ageing team could hamper the likes of Wallace, O’Connell (if he’s ever fit), O’Driscoll and their bench. Scotland have, possibly, more promise and longevity in their front 5. However, unless things change in our youth policy 6th could be as far as we go.

S.A. are beatable. We’ve done it before, and we can actually take on the big boys at home. In the end, though, kicking won’t do it; we need tries. Teams will always score against the Bokke, and really we have to score more than they do. This means creating space and the backs actually passing when someone else is in the space. Jackson is raw enough to spot this, and arrogant enough to take a gap. What we need is Southwell to maybe listen to men outside him, a designated back-rower behind Evans (if he plays, ‘cos faced with a defence he will only ever offload when caught, he’ll never pass in front of contact) and we should let some prospects play. Give youth a chance to grow.

Get Weir training with the squad, let Jim Thompson come off the bench, keep Vernon in even though the last match passed him by a little, let Laidlaw abuse the pack even if Blair isn’t injured and petition the EU and IRB about Visser’s Visa and allegiances. All of this may not pay dividends against South Africa, Samoa or even in the 6N, but it should help come World Cup time, because we have a greater depth in the squad and more experience going into the future. No one wants a repeat of Black Saturday and I’m not fast enough to keep playing tig with the busses.

Support N50 Sports

4 Responses

  1. We should feel confident against the Boks,
    the situation we find ourselves in finds is similar to that of 2008. Got hammered by NZ, then the week later came within 4 of RSA (and should definitely have beaten them) .
    like you said i’d like to see Laidlaw and Jackson start, they both looked exciting when they came on, and made ground unlike others around them.

  2. You’re right about the ground; Scotland made about 8-10 offloads in the first half that the BBC commentators were desperately praising. Problem was that for the 10 phases this happenned in we didn’t move past the 10m line.
    By all means we need the offloads, but we have to go forward first.
    There will be more gaps against S.A. and, who knows, they may be mentally worn down by the drug ban news

  3. If the Boks are ‘beatable’ then Scotland need possession out wide, sorry guys the Bok fetchers seem up to the task despite the question marks around Kankowski and Stegman, tackle counts by the Irish over the 140 mark, does Scotland have the fitness to live with the frontal assault of the Boks? The secret lies in the backline overlaps and the ability to pass inward with the angles being run at high speed. breaking the tackle and offloading before they go to ground .

You might also like these:

World Rugby has taken steps to ban Dupont's Law amongst three new law changes to be brought in in July.
Scotland came up frustratingly short in their final Six Nations match against Ireland, losing out on a place in WXV1 in the dying minutes. It was a disappointing end to what has been a very good, if not spectacular, tournament from Scotland. Eleanor has the talking points.
Scotland's Womens Six Nations came to a frustrating end with an eminently achievable third place slipping out of their fingers in the final minutes. Skye rates the players.
Scotland Women travel to Ireland this weekend to face down the chance of their first 3rd place finish in the Six Nations since 2005.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion