Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Analysing the All Blacks

At 5.15 on Saturday a few boys may get the shock of their lives. According to the grumpy headmaster Graham Henry respects Scotland enough not to tinker…too much.

Al is right, the All Blacks aren’t Supermen. So looking at our team selection and the way NZ coasted past England in 2nd gear, what do we expect?

Well, if Henry picks a similar side then we can take heart from the fact that the scrum wasn’t looking world class. Despite playing very little rugby, Murray should be able to hold on, particularly as Mealamu is out following his citing. In this instance Ross Ford will, thankfully, be able to rely on his Test match experience, rather than his form, against debutant Hika Elliot. Chunk will do what Chunk does.

If we expect an even contest in the line-out, then set-piece won’t be too harem-scarem. In the loose, however, the All Black forwards come into play. The younger guys should retain their places, so expect to see Whitelock and Franks running around. The former is an athletic second-row (with the exception of Troy Flavell, aren’t they all?!) and the latter is a savage at the breakdown. It was quite pleasing seeing him brutally smash Ben Foden last Saturday, but watch him smash into rucks from miles away this Saturday.

Whilst we’re on the subject of breakdowns, it is time to point out the flaw from Sky’s coverage of the ABs last week. Dan Carter wasn’t the Man of the Match…Kieran Read was. If he starts, then as well as shoeing McCaw away from the wrong side of the ruck, the Scottish back-row of Brown, Barclay and Vernon are going to have to find some way of slowing Read down. If he doesn’t do the dirty work, the rest of the NZ breakaways cough up penalties.

Where optimism lies, however, is in our defence. If we chase kicks well then hopefully Muliaina, or whoever starts at 15, won’t be able to draw men before feeding Toeava or Gear through the gap. Also the ABs will expect kicking…but our 11,12,13 and 14 aren’t hugely fond of kicking…or passing, really. Maybe if the mood takes we can spring a surprise. That would be lovely, wouldn’t it?!

The Kiwi rugby forums all tell of respect but they all say the same thing; Scotland kick out of desperation and have no cutting edge. The 20pt win predictions they are offering are based on assumptions that counter-attack will shred Scotland. If we can claim turnovers and unleash the Lamont brothers of years ago, maybe we can add some tries to those kicks.

p.s. Message for Max Evans; don’t let Sonny Bill offload if he starts. Ta.

UPDATE: NZ Team: Muliaina, Toeava, Smith, Williams, Gear, Carter, Cowan, Woodcock, Mealamu / Elliot, Franks, Thorn, Whitelock, Messam, McCaw, Read

Support N50 Sports

6 Responses

  1. Certainly seems a fair analysis to me! Agree about Sonny Bill offloading – didn’t do a huge amount against England but you’ve got to think he’s got class.

    For me so much of Scotland’s game is down to concentration. If they can keep mentally focussed and not allow themselves to be put off focus then they can certainly compete. I think the great thing about the NZ team is there ability to win the mind games, they just ooze a level of threat that other teams just don’t have. It’s a times like this you need the Scotland team to be mentally strong…keep the head and the rest will follow!

  2. on the flipside, if Scotland can offload succesfully in close-contact, we can achieve momentum.
    Interested to see Richie Vernon running in open space and Brown sacrificing himself to take out the NZ turnover threat.

  3. Absolutely – would love to see Scotland executing the offloads that suck in defenders. It’s an aspect of the Scotland game that has improved recently but it really needs to be precise – anything sloppy will just lead to easy turnover ball and NZ will murder you!

  4. The thing that always scares me about the ABs is that they are almost at their most threatening when you think you are doing well – for example you pinch a lineout but before you have time to shout WOOO you fumble the recovery and suddenly they’re all over you streaming through the gaps that you hadn’t thought about because you had just started thinking about attack…

  5. Oh man that wound me up. Am thinking the Friday post should be simply a picture of the mooning scene from Braveheart with the header, “Response to the Haka”

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards
Craig is joined by John on the injured reserve list to have a wee look at the URC action from the weekend.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion