Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Edinburgh 17-18 Cardiff Blues

Blair Kinghorn is congratulated by Magnus Bradbury
Blair Kinghorn is congratulated by Magnus Bradbury and teammates after scoring for Edinburgh Rugby - pic © Alastair Ross / Novantae Photography

It was a damp affair at Myreside but Richard Cockerill’s cockles will have been warmed over in France by the way the home pack performed, well marshalled in the set piece by Ben Toolis and Neil Cochrane.

A period of opening dominance and a series of mauls saw a yellow card to Cardiff prop Anton Peikrishvili and a pushover try from the pack, following on the heels of Steve Shingler opening the scoring with a penalty early on.

The Blues (playing in pink) hit back straight away with another Shingler penalty – these lapses are the sort of thing the new coach will be trying to stamp out.

Fraser McKenzie and Blair Kinghorn took a lot of treatment but battled on manfully, and every time the Edinburgh pack took a grip of the ball they were punishing Cardiff one way or the other. Into the wind, Sam Hidalgo-Clyne couldn’t make the kicks count but the pack were exerting strong territorial pressure.

Cardiff were well and truly on the wrong side of referee David Wilkinson and were having a miserable introduction to Myreside with a second yellow card (this time for Jarrod Hoetea) on the half hour mark. They were well on the way to a 4-card bonus point!

McKenzie succumbed to his injury just before half time but was replaced by Lewis Carmichael and not as you may have expected by erstwhile Scotland captain Grant Gilchrist, who didn’t make it on apart from a ten minute spell for Magnus Bradbury – perhaps that might have been a mistake.

A brief cameo by Kinghorn at 10 saw a nice jinked kick in behind Cardiff that Michael Allen (Tovey was off for an HIA) only just failed to gather.

There’s always a gripe with Edinburgh and it was that in a half where their maul was dominant and their opponents misfired consistently in the lineout, and played with a man down for 50% of the half, the score at half-time was only 7-6.

Half-time: 7-6

The Edinburgh backs came out with renewed confidence in the second half and for a while it paid off.

Rory Scholes scored a superb try on 48 minutes after a nice pop out from Kinghorn from a set scrum move; refreshingly the winger backed his pace to round Matthew Morgan and dive over in the corner.

Edinburgh used their dominance to good effect, the backline suddenly finding holes and Scholes finding another try in the opposite corner. Conversions were tricky for Sam Hidalgo-Clyne in the blustery wind but 17-6 was a comfortable lead and the bonus point a genuine possibility.

Sion Bennett gave the home crowd pause for thought with a try on the hour mark that was a little too easily carved through Edinburgh’s midfield. The defensively sleepy periods that have killed Edinburgh of late were looming over the stands at Myreside.

The visitors upped the intensity and the offloading considerably at that point, sensing a genuine chance at 17-13 to win the game, never mind slinking off with a losing bonus. Edinburgh obliged by dropping off tackles enough to give the momentum.

The final ten minutes began with Cardiff camped in Edinburgh’s half and a penaty kick to the corner. Only a superb tackle by Hidalgo-Clyne held Cuthbert up but Cardiff kept bashing.

When Edinburgh infringed in the ruck – possibly Toolis fractionally round the side – Cardiff took the speculative option on the advantage and regathered the chip kick to take a single point lead. The conversion was oddly missed but it certainly helped the final minutes for drama.

Tom James was pinged for a high tackle and Kinghorn – on a night when almost no kicks went over – missed a medium range penalty with just 4 minutes to play.

Cardiff’s defence was up to the task of the endless inneffectual carries by Edinburgh – at one point Cornell du Preez took the ball stationery and stood for a good 5 seconds deciding what to do – and when the ball popped out of Hidalgo-Clyne’s hands he was able to regather but he was swamped by Blues players who made it a maul the ball was never coming out of.

Edinburgh will be gutted but as usual a lack of leadership late on and sporadic drops in intensity are killing them. You can’t blame that all on the backline.

SRBlog Man of the Match: Sam Hidalgo-Clyne had his best game in ages and Kinghorn was lively as ever, but I’m giving it to captain Neil Cochrane who leads from the front every time. A nuggety Scottish hooker, you’ve got to wonder what sort of player he’d be if he’d had the chances Ross Ford has.

8 Responses

  1. That last quarter was embarrassing, woeful, pathetic. Whatever you want to call it.

    Cardiff had the wind in the first half, and spent 20 minutes shorthanded. Edinburgh did well into the breeze to turn round in front. Second half started so brightly, but then it began to go wrong – poor tackling again, for the third week in a row, no-one specifically at fault as it was a team problem. Poor kicking with the wind handing the ball back to Cardiff time after time, then a lack of any penetration in the dying moments.

    This should have been a comfortable BP win. I really don’t know how Edinburgh managed to turn it into a loss.

    And for those pushing Cornell du Preez for a Scotland cap. Watch his performances over the last three weeks, then have a quiet word with yourselves. He is nowhere near international quality.

  2. Ade, I’d previously advocated CdP for a stating place in the Scotland team, on the evidence of his last 3 games he is indeed nowhere near justifying this.

    However the man himself is not the same man that I saw last season where in some games his combination of brute force & soft hands were a joy to behold.

    Re the game last night one last musing – i’m assuming the current coaching staff are only still there courtesy of their contracts?

  3. Another shambolic schizophrenic performance. The coaches have lost the dressing-room. Cockerill should be given a free hand to drain the swamp if Edinburgh are to compete again at the top end of the Pro-12. That means taxi for Hodge.
    If Edinburgh were getting regally humped every match then the problem can be attributed to the players who are just not good enough. There are a number of good players in the squad who are able to get the team into potentially winning positions. Poor coaching, along with mental weakness, is at the root of the Edinburgh problem.

    1. Although I understand that the current coaches have mortgages and commitments, this is a tough professional sport, and is supposed to be a ruthlessly ‘results based’ business.
      Not much sign of ruthlessness exhibited here. How can their current coaches roles be justified. Loss after loss. Poor performance after poor performance.
      Reading in ‘the Hootsman’ that Hodge was ‘dissapointed that he wasn’t offered the top job. How crazy is that? Performance should be written into any contract.

  4. The poor second half performances can only to be due to woeful fitness and conditionining. What a shambles of a club right now.

  5. Having spent a hour or 2 watching, reading “stuff” about Richard Cockerill I’d assume he will want to go “through” Edinburgh Rugby like the preverbal dose of salts????

    The Kinghorn missed penalty attempt (where a blind man could see the kick to the corner was the better option), the hideously poor aimless brainless kicking, the fact that fit strong men stayed sat on the bench whilst injured/knackered men stayed on the pitch, the horrible feeling KNOWING that despite being ahead Edinburgh WERE going to lose the game.

  6. I don’t see Edinburgh very often and was shocked with how directionless they look. I”m no expert but looks like a coaching issue/leadership issue. Fitness wise they look well short of Glasgow.

    Du Preez doesn’t look fit and neither did Gilchrist when he came on. Bradbury clearly injured in second half- why left on?

    Though Ritchie was decent, Hidalgo-Clyne was OK. I can’t see many of those Edinburgh players troubling the Scotland selectors soon.

    Cockerill may be seen as many as not being an expansive coach but surely better than where they are right now.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion