Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


1872 Matchups: Round One

In which we (well, I) take a look at the various Scotland matchups that took place over the first 1872 Cup leg, to see if things are any clearer for Andy Robinson, and I suppose his new “guru” Scott Johnson. Of course this is just how I saw it, so if you think differently please let us know in the comments section.

Front Row

MacArthur isn’t really challenging Ford for the Scotland shirt – no-one is, but in the props it is less clear cut. Chunk is a starter if fit and he galvanised Edinburgh when he came on, but then also gave away crucial penalties. Supporting roles as stand-ins for first choice Chunk, Ford and Euan Murray are all up for grabs though, with Geoff Cross now probably the clear second choice prop ahead of Moray Low and he would likely make the top spot on Sundays. No one in this game particularly made a case, although Cusack and MacArthur for Glasgow went well in the scrums.

Second Row

Less of a matchup this and more of a “who will partner Richie?”. The big man set about Edinburgh’s lineout with aplomb, at one point stealing 3 in a row and illustrating just what a useful tool standing about at the front waving your arms can be when you are 7 feet tall. In the loose he is a marked man now and this should continue in the next Six Nations. As a result his impact on games seems a little less than this time last year, or as AD says “posted missing”. His captain Al Kellock also played well after an early injury knocked him on his backside, taking a crucial try to keep Glasgow in the game and leading from the front with a little help from his half-backs. On the Edinburgh side, Gilichrist played well and may yet show enough to make the training squad, but he’ll have to beat off Mackenzie and possibly even Vernon from Sale to make it in alongside Hamilton. The two Glasgow boys: currently out in front.

David Denton vs Rob Harley

Tricky one this. Both players have been to the fore in their respective league campaigns thus far this season, but here they seemed almost to cancel each other out. Harley’s frigid defence came up against Denton’s rampaging attack – a microcosm of their team styles really.

Ross Rennie vs John Barclay

Barclay has been the holder of the 7 shirt for a long time while Rennie has had to recover from injury after injury so a lot could be made of this matchup. This season he has been well-managed and it is starting to pay off. He got a try as a result of good support work going forward, while Barclay as usual was everywhere in defence – including all the places Edinburgh would rather he wasn’t, slowing down or stealing ball – but a little anonymous going forward ball in hand. Rennie also deserves plaudits of sorts for not getting injured in a nasty clash with that other injury-berserker Rory Lamont, who left the field after a lengthy treatment.

Mike Blair vs Chris Cusiter

This one has generated a bit of debate already. Bill Johnstone commented on the BBC Radio Scotland coverage that he felt Blair was having a marvellous game, almost at the exact moment I thought out loud what a good game Cusiter was having. Cusiter made far more breaks although Blair threw himself about in defence all over the park. Some of his passes seemed to me to be a little high, forcing his first receiver to jump or at least stay still and losing the momentum Edinburgh so clearly thrive on, while Cusiter was throwing them lower and delivering quicker. If you look at the end result, Cusiter had a far greater influence on it as he, Jackson and Kellock dragged the Glasgow team back into the game and Cusiter’s speculative box kick into Murrayfield’s mammoth in-goal area gave them the draw. Why he wasn’t given Man of the Match is a little beyond me.

Greig Laidlaw vs Duncan Weir/Ruaridh Jackson

So far, not much learned. Laidlaw won this matchup possibly by virtue of not making as many mistakes as Weir or Jackson made during their stints. Jackson came on and popped up for his try on the end of Cusiter’s up and under but he’d made a few dodgy calls before that. All three proved basically what we already suspected: Weir has a big boot, Jackson likes to attack but can be flaky and Laidlaw can run an attacking game brilliantly from 9 or 10. But can he control a defensive kicking effort under test levels of pressure?


No direct match-ups here (based on previous selections anyway) although James King I suppose could be an outside bet for a squad place. Arguably Robinson’s two favourite centres were on show though, in the shape of Morrison and De Luca. Of those two probably De Luca looked the better, making some good breaks and throwing some fizzing passes compared to Morrison who made some good breaks and threw very few passes. Would he consider a De Luca / Ansbro pairing?

Back Three

Mossy was playing opposite Stuart Hogg (who along with Lee Jones for Edinburgh, seemed to get little ball to work with), but as the elder statesman of Scottish rugby announced his retirement this week and Lemi and Visser were in the mix too we didn’t learn much about potential Scotland back three slots. Other than this: Tim Visser – who skinned Lamont early on – could be a key ingredient in next year’s Scotland recipe.

Support N50 Sports

4 Responses

  1. I agree with the second row, Al Kellock & Richie Gray have been playing well & i thimk it will be a shame if Al isn’t Scotland captain because he is such good & natural leader.
    To me Chris Cusiter was clearly better than Mikr Blair, he seems to have returned to his best form & he should be Scotlands first choice scrum half imo.
    The fly halves are interesting, Weir didn’t have his best game but he landed his kicks and is still much more reliable than Jackson. Laidlaw played well but I think his best position is scrum half. I think Scotlands best bet at fly half is Weir, I don’t like the idea of relying on Ruaridh Jackson to kick for Scotland

  2. Is Vernon really a candidate for lock in your eyes, or did I read that wrong? He’s hardly got the bulk for 8, never mind 4 or 5.

  3. Agree with MJW. Think it is very unlikely Vernon would be considered as a lock. He’s a luxury player really. Good guy to be able to bring off the bench when the game has broken up as got good pace but pretty ineffectual in an attritional forwards’ battle. It also really irritates me when that he always checks when he breaks off the back of the scrum, I assume because he doesn’t like contact. He should use his pace to take him away from the opposition back row, as he did in that 1872 game a few years back. Personally, I would have Brown, Stroker, Harley and Denton ahead of him at 6, and Beattie, Denton, McInally, Brown and Wilson ahead of him at 8. No need for him in the squad I reckon.

    Ansbro and de Luca in the centres could be worth a shot but both of them are really better suited to the 13 shirt. Saying that I am up for them trying new ideas if it means Morrison not being selected. For me the form Scots qualified 12 at the moment is King and he and de Luca are playing well as a pairing. Think AR might consider him too small though. De Luca seems to be the form 13 at the moment asndAnsbro also playing well. I would quite like to see de Luca at 13 and Ansbro on the wing. He’s a good 13 but has also proven himself to be a clinical finisher on the wing.

    Unfortunately in our main problem position 10, there was no clear winner in the first leg. I would go with Weir to start but have Laidlaw on the bench. In fact you could maybe go with Laidlaw and Jackson on the bench which provides you with a number of options at 10, depending on how the game pans out, as well as cover at 9 and another goalkicker (Laidlaw rather than Jackson). Whatever you go for AR please don’t revert to Parks.

    Also have banged on about it before but really hope we also don’t see the return of Southwell.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by John on the injured reserve list to have a wee look at the URC action from the weekend.
World Rugby has taken steps to ban Dupont's Law amongst three new law changes to be brought in in July.
Scotland came up frustratingly short in their final Six Nations match against Ireland, losing out on a place in WXV1 in the dying minutes. It was a disappointing end to what has been a very good, if not spectacular, tournament from Scotland. Eleanor has the talking points.
Scotland's Womens Six Nations came to a frustrating end with an eminently achievable third place slipping out of their fingers in the final minutes. Skye rates the players.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion