After a chastening return to the normal order of things last weekend, and an even more humbling display by Wales against the All Blacks the day previous, Scotland took to the Murrayfield pitch as the final northern hemisphere side without a victory this weekend.
After sustained possession, the hosts opened the scoring inside ten minutes with a Matt Fagerson try. The flanker was lurking on the wing bellowing for the ball, and Ben White had the vision to whip it out to him. A foot further infield and Finn Russell might have converted; as it was he knocked it off the post.
Australia’s riposte was instant: Harry Potter making the most of that rarest of passing techniques, take and give along the line. Add in an ineffective tackle from Russell – who was matching that up with some fairly haphazard kicking at that point – to even the scores.
Tom Jordan was a late swap in at inside centre for skipper Sione Tuipulotu who had been struggling with injury all week, and he got involved with a number of short carries. It was a fierce scrap at the breakdown and he wasn’t shy of it in attack or defence.
The scrum was a battle too, referee James Doleman awarding regular free kicks against the home front row.
Australia had little possession outside of the referee’s gifts, but were choosing a selection of well-placed kicks that kept Russell and Blair Kinghorn pinned back in their own half.
Record try scorer Darcy Graham had another attempt knocked off for Kyle Steyn (only just) being out of play when kicking the ball back in goal for the winger to pounce on.
Dempsey, facing the team he used to represent and perhaps wanting to make up for an off week against NZ, managed an actual try from close range, to lengthen out the lead but once again a soft scrum offence gave Australia a penalty, then a lineout in the Scottish 22. The men in navy defended stoutly, but the Wallabies mauled it over at the second time of asking. That one too was chalked off by the TMO, this time for the lifter obstructing in the maul.
Scotland clung on into half time but in addition to the skipper not starting, Steyn (HIA) and Cummings (leg) had both been replaced, and the scrum was a source of easy ball for the visitors.
Plenty to work on.
Half-time: Scotland 12-5 Australia
Scotland came out at pace, continuing their tactic of probing grubber kicks rather than forcing the pass in the wider channels. With Billy Pollard in the bin for a high contact on Kinghorn, and Steyn passing his HIA it seemed like Scotland had momentum back, but furious defensive pressure from the men in gold meant Scotland struggled to impose any rhythm to their game.

There was an almost complete lack of Huw Jones in the game, but Jordan was still determined to do the work of two men. When Jones did get the ball he looked half a yard faster than anyone on the pitch and it was frustrating he had so little to do.
With plenty replacements on for both sides, it continued as a fierce but scrappy contest with very little width and both sides defensive systems evenly matched. It wasn’t going to take much to decide it one way or the other.
Scotland couldn’t break the Wallaby defence down enough to go hunting the try bonus they probably wanted in terms of the wider tournament. As it was, an easily kicked Russell penalty put them a score clear with five minutes to go, which was lucky as Australia scored a late converted try to set the teeth of the Murrayfield crowd on edge and make it a nervy finish.
It was oddly frustrating stuff. If the Nations Championship wasn’t a thing we’d likely applaud it as a professional win over capable Southern Hemisphere opposition – a rare thing in past decades.
It just feels like more than nine years into Townsend’s rapidly dwindling era in charge we need a little more from Scotland.
SRBlog Player of the Match: Tom Jordan was a fizzbomb-slash-nuisance of energy in attack and defence but in a day settled at the breakdown, Rory Darge had several keenly timed interventions that ultimately snuffed out the Australian fightback.