Despite it being just three years since South Africa last visited Murrayfield, less than 50% of the players who featured in 2018 return this time round. 13 of the Springbok 23 played in that win over Scotland, with 6 of them starting both fixtures.
Nine Scots return from South Africa’s last visit in the early days of the Townsend era. Stuart Hogg, Finn Russell, Stuart McInally and Sam Skinner are the only 2018 starters who have been retained.
Tale of the tape
BACKS
51 Tries 60
94kg Average weight 91kg
266 Total caps 283
28.2 Average age 29.4
FORWARDS
922kg Pack weight 895kg
16 Tries 24
195 Total caps 386
27.8 Average age 30.6
SUBSTITUTES
141 Total caps 342
26 Tries 41
26.2 Average age 29.7
4 Scotland changes from last Test (v Australia)
- 14 – McLean for Graham [=]
- 12 – Scott for Johnson [-]
- 2 – McInally for Turner [=]
- 6/7 – Haining for Watson with Ritchie from 6 to 7 [-]
SCOTLAND
15 Stuart Hogg (c)
14 Rufus McLean
13 Chris Harris
12 Matt Scott
11 Duhan van der Merwe
10 Finn Russell
9 Ali Price
1 Pierre Schoeman
2 Stuart McInally
3 Zander Fagerson
4 Sam Skinner
5 Grant Gilchrist
6 Nick Haining
7 Jamie Ritchie
8 Matt Fagerson
16 Ewan Ashman
17 Jamie Bhatti
18 Oli Kebble
19 Jamie Hodgson
20 Hamish Watson
21 George Horne
22 Adam Hastings
23 Blair Kinghorn
HEAD-TO-HEAD
ADV Scotland
ADV Scotland
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV Scotland
ADV Scotland
ADV Scotland
EVEN
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
EVEN
EVEN
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV Scotland
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
ADV South Africa
SOUTH AFRICA
Willie le Roux 15
Jesse Kriel 14
Lukhanyo Am 13
Damian de Allende 12
Makazole Mapimpi 11
Elton Jantjies 10
Herschel Jantjies 9
Ox Nche 1
Bongi Mbonambi 2
Trevor Nyakane 3
Eben Etzebeth 4
Franco Mostert 5
Kwagga Smith 7
Siya Kolisi (c) 6
Duane Vermeulen 8
Malcolm Marx 16
Steven Kitshoff 17
Vincent Koch 18
Lood de Jager 19
Jasper Wiese 20
Cobus Reinach 21
Handre Pollard 22
Francois Steyn 23
Overall
Backs – advantage Scotland
Scotland’s five Lions are all present and correct among the backline. For various reasons they will each feel they have unfinished business against the Springboks. Ali Price and Finn Russell will have the most influence when it comes to imposing the Scottish gameplan. If they can play off any kind of decent ball then expect fireworks!
While there are some differences in the South African backs compared to the lineups that tackled the Lions, what won’t have changed is the intensity they will bring. That will be particularly apparent in their defensive linespeed and kick chase. The visitors also possess turnover threats across their XV – right through to winger, Makazole Mapimpi. Scotland’s protection of the ball will need to be absolutely on point.
Forwards – advantage South Africa
Over the past 4 years if there is one side that could be seen as kryptonite for Gregor Townsend’s Scotland it’s Ireland. The Irish physicality and aggression at the breakdown has set them up for a series of wins and even when the Scots have come close to matching them it hasn’t been enough.
The South African approach in this area is like a supercharged version of Ireland’s forward 8. With both of these nations in Scotland’s RWC pool, a game like this is one of a very small number of remaining opportunities for the Scottish forwards to prove they can go toe to toe with a pack of this quality at ruck and maul – as well as scrum and lineout.
Subs – advantage South Africa
The additions of Hamish Watson and Blair Kinghorn to the bench adds experience to what was a pretty raw group for the Australia game. Countering the South African bomb squad and friends (who collectively have 200 more caps than the Scottish subs) will be a massive challenge. It’s going to take a 23-man performance from the home side to come away with a first win against the Springboks for more than a decade.
Miscellany
– Scotland are looking for their 4th win in the calendar year against a side ranked in the top 3 in the world. Gregor Townsend already has 6 victories against top 3 sides under his belt during his 4½ years in charge – that’s 1 more than the 5 wins managed by Scotland in the other 13½ years since the rankings were introduced in 2003. Scotland victories v top 3 ranked sides:
- 2021 v Australia (3rd) at Murrayfield
- 2021 v France (3rd) at Stade de France
- 2021 v England (2nd) at Twickenham
- 2018 v England (2nd) at Murrayfield
- 2017 v Australia (3rd) at Murrayfield
- 2017 v Australia (3rd) at Allianz Stadium
- 2012 v Australia (2nd) at Hunter Stadium
- 2010 v South Africa (2nd) at Murrayfield
- 2009 v Australia (3rd) at Murrayfield
- 2008 v Argentina (3rd) at José Amalfitani Stadium
- 2006 v France (3rd) at Murrayfield
– Scotland are also looking for just their third ever win against reigning world champions. The dark blues defeated England in 2006 and South Africa in 2010 when both sides held the Webb Ellis Cup.
– Stuart Hogg will make his 87th start at full back in a Test match (85 for Scotland, 2 for the Lions). That is the most for any male player in international rugby, overtaking Rob Kearney’s 86 (84 for Ireland, 2 for the Lions).
– The spectacular finish by Ewan Ashman against Australia was the 160th try of the Townsend era (3.40 tries per game v 1.98 tries per game for the rest of the professional era). That’s 26.5% of the tries scored in the pro era in just 17.3% of the matches played.
– Francois Steyn will be making his fourth appearance at Murrayfield for South Africa. Way back in 2007 he started at 13 opposite Andy Henderson. In 2008 he replaced Jean de Villiers and faced off versus Nick de Luca. When Scotland last beat the Springboks in 2010, Steyn was at outside centre where he was up against Joe Ansbro.
– This is the first time in 2021 (8th game of the year) that either Stuart McInally or Fraser Brown have started at hooker for Scotland after they dominated the number 2 shirt over the previous 4 years, starting 33 out of 37 games.
– The Scotland 23 have a combined caps tally in excess of 600 for just the second time since the 2019 RWC.
