Site icon Scottish Rugby Blog

Scotland vs Tonga – The Player Ratings

Ali Dickinson - pic © Al Ross

Ali Dickinson - pic © Al Ross

15. Stuart Hogg – distinctly left the high balls he found difficult last week to Beattie, which improved the overall perception of his performance. Plenty of attacking panache 7.5/10

14. Tommy Seymour – solid but given less to do switched to the other wing. Good winger’s positioning for his try and the setup for Hogg’s 7

13. Sean Lamont – unspectacular but solid, which sums up his career in 3 words. Held on well in defence in the face of nuggety Tongan runners 7

12. Alex Dunbar – poor first half (echoing a quiet Autumn so far) but significantly upped his game. Suspect Cotter had a word at half time. Superb second half and very strong for his try, could have had a second 8

11. Tim Visser – slow start for his first game of the series, however his game improved with some nice carries. Had a few near chances, but defensive positioning is still suspect on occasion 7

10. Finn Russell – gbarring a  charge down had another solid game. Good game management, kicking generally solid and always looking for space to run into. Good awareness for to create the impetus for Cross’s try 8

9. Greig Laidlaw – as he has been all month, outstanding. Quick ball, kicked well from hand, service much improved and consistently the fulcrum around which the Scotland team pivots 9

1. Alasdair Dickinson – Industrious particularly in the first half, solid in the scrum. An extra helper at the breakdown 8

2. Ross Ford – vastly improved in recent weeks. Carried well again and may even have tried to hook in the scrum 7

3. Geoff Cross – deserved his try, put in a typical front-rower’s performance, with plenty of blood snotters and beard hair 7

4. Richie Gray – good in the loose even appearing in the midfield a few times. Consistently threatening the opposition lineout 7

5. Jonny Gray – quieter than last week but still made 13 tackles (none missed). Coughed up 2 penalties but Scotland look stronger at the set piece mainly due to him 7.5

6. Rob Harley – another decent game, but not as impressive as last week with the Tongan runners very hard to disrupt. Still has a lot to offer Scotland but will have better days at the office 6

7. Blair Cowan – another outstanding performance, starting to look like a fixture in the starting XV. Does the simple things very well (running, tackling, snaffling ball) and fully deserved his try. 9

8. Johnnie Beattie – bearing in mind he’s feeling the heat from Adam Ashe, he can be pleased with his day’s work. Strong running and looking positive under the high ball. Still has a lot to offer Scotland, but we won’t mention the kicking 7

Replacements

Strengths of the starting XV meant the bench was used sparingly.

16. Fraser Brown – not much remarkable but hit his opening lineout throw 6

17. Gordon Reid – only on for a short time, shored up the scrum well 6

18. Ryan Grant – only on for a few mintues, but managed a nice sidestep in that time 6

19. Kieran Low n/a

20. Al Strokosch – the usual! Solid but unspectacular 6

21. Chris Cusiter n/a

22. Duncan Weir n/a

23. Duncan Taylor – contributed to Seymour’s try, looked good on the ball 7

Exit mobile version