Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Scotland 30-29 Italy

Matt Scott - photo © Alastair Ross

We worried that Scotland wouldn’t show up, and they started like they were still asleep as impressive Italian winger Sarto scampered over for a converted try inside 2 minutes.

Scotland settled into it pretty quickly after that with some excellent offloading from Matt Scott almost putting Seymour through. Last week the pass was behind him but this week he over-ran it. Minutes later Denton’s accuracy was spot on though as he put Scott into space behind the Italian gain line and Scott danced round the straggling defenders for another great try. The two combined soon after as Denton flailed at Scott’s chip at the line. He missed but it caused enough chaos for Laidlaw to pop the ball out wide to Lamont for Scotland’s second try.

Scotland had the edge when the ball went through the hands even if both sides were playing with enterprise in the sunshine, but Italy with Castrogiovanni were in control at the scrums. A mullering of Alasdair Dickinson saw the Italians awarded a penalty try by referee Leighton Hodges to keep the scores close at 17-17 and a further penalty each meant they went in tied at half time 20-20.

Scotland’s midfield of Scott and Dunbar had made a lot of ground, and Lamont and Swinson battered holes at every opportunity. The Italian centres too displayed some class while Di Bernardo was a reassuring presence at 9, kicking his goals well.

Could the second half be as good as the first or would it tighten up much as the Lions first test had? Laidlaw and Di Bernardo exchanged penalties to keep things even and set the tone. There would be perhaps three key battles: Castro vs Dickinson in the scrum, Laidlaw vs Di Bernardo with the boot and everyone else vs Sergio Parisse. Honours about even all round except for the first one where Italy had the clear edge in the set piece.

Tim Visser, who has had a low profile all tour, came off the bench with half an hour to play looking for work and after a few half chances to make an impact, he put Matt Scott under the posts with an offload out the back door. However the TMO and referee Hodges ruled it was forward to leave the game tied. Visser hasn’t had it all his way since the summer tour last year and it will be interesting to see how he responds now Seymour, Murchie and Duncan have caps, especially with Nikki Walker and Jack Cuthbert pitching up at Edninburgh next season. Big competition for back three places, even before you take into account our Lions.

As the bench emptying began and with Castrogiovanni off there was a slight lull as the cagey business of winning an international reared its head. Both sides probed and the nice offloading continued with defence looking fairly sound on both sides. Heathcote was replaced by Laidlaw as Pyrgos came on, with the young Bath man looking like he may have taken a knock, but he had emerged with some credit having defended and moved the backline well.

Italy moved ahead with another penalty as the level of niggle raised and Di Bernardo slotted another one minutes later. Italy were quietly building a lead and although Scotland still looked better with the ball in hand a converted try rapidly became the only option.

You know how good we are chasing the game, so a sustained period of Scots pressure on the Italian 22 saw no greater reward than Greig Laidlaw getting a wee kick in the head from Parisse as he clambered over a ruck.

It was 23-29 with ten minutes to play as Fraser Brown got his first cap, and the Scots kept the pressure up but Italy were getting the decisions. It had all the hallmarks of another one that got away, especially with scrums eating up the clock – even if the Scots were now competing at that set piece.

As the clock wound down Scotland had one chance to score the try that would win it, but where some extra final gasping effort would have perhaps seen them home, Scotland did not look liks they had enough left in the tank to break through a contracting Italian defence.

No one told Al Strokosch.

Near heroic against South Africa and relatively quiet this week, the Big Stroker stepped up as Scotland hammered the Italian line and that man Parisse slipped out of the line in defence. A gap behind him opened up and the blindside playing at openside slid through it to dot down.  Scotland had got out of jail against Italy again.

They should have won last week but didn’t; this week it’s debatable but they ground out a win nevertheless.

SR Blog Man of the Match: Matt Scott. Give him a couple of years and this lad could be truly great. Marshalled the defence, broke the line at every opportunity and offloaded superbly as he did this week. Having nearly lost out to Pete Horne in the first game of the Six Nations, he’s turned fortune around and has been Scotland’s player of the tour and I can’t wait to see him in a Scotland shirt in the autumn. Honourable mentions to Swinson and Strokosch.

6 Responses

  1. Samoa result was a shocker but I think this series has been used well by Scotland. Strokosch has had a great tour as has Scott. I’ve been calling for Lamont to go for 3 seasons now but on the wing this summer he has been impressive. Still not convinced on Laidlaws sipped of delivery and tendency to kick but his goals are crucial. Heathcote is our future 10 I hope they don’t stick Hogg there. Visser may find it tough to get into the 15 now new blood has been capped given his appalling defence. Front row is my main concern going forward. Ryan grant aside I am unconvinced by any of them on the international stage.

  2. Feels like a step backwards after last weeks performance even though it was a win. Possibly could have been more comfortable if the ref had bothered to enforce the offside, the Italians seems to spend all day there without penalty. Some very tired players by the end and the constant stoppages for italian ‘injuries’ killed the momentum of the second half. Moray low had a stinker of a half in the scrum and i hadnt even realised beattie was still playing in the second half before harley came on. Matt scott was everywhere again and lamont worked hard all day, which should annoy some of his naysayers!

    Some positives but still a work in progress i feel.

  3. The refereeing in many games has been poor. Often refs that I’m unfamiliar with. I guess these are new to international rugby?

    1. I have just re-watched the match on Full Rugby Matches on Youtube ( well worth subscribing, its free too) and i cannot believe how cynical the Italians were. I counted several occasions when the second and third arrivals at the tackled threw themselves over the ball off their feet, the Italian midfield was offside umpteen times, the hindmost foot of a ruck seemed to be somewhere nearer our side of the ruck than theirs, and there were a few times i noticed little cheap shots from them too, little back of the hand efforts as players went by, dropped knees in players backs etc. Hodges was oblivious or chose to ignore it. Even the Saffer commentators were getting annoyed at how they were getting away with it. They had no axe to grind and were purring over Matt Scott for his general play. Jean de Villiers without the whiney attitude!

      Perhaps George Clancy is now training up other refs to be as useless as he his. If cloning was possible, get Nigel Owens in a lab quickly. Alas, knowing the luck we have, they would clone Alain Rolland!

  4. Laidlaw played well again today, shame he had to be moved to the 10 position. Scott played out of his socks yet again and showed some great skill, Dunbar hasn’t sold me to be honest and I’m looking forward to seeing Bennett complete the centre pairing.

    Heathcote wasn’t great at 10, Jackson seems to have matured under Townsend and I’m thinking more and more of him as the future there for Scotland. Weir would currently be second choice for me.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by Jonny and Iain to look forward to Glasgow's huge URC final in Pretoria, after the win against Munster and skirt around the latest news of the week.
Craig is joined by Jonny and Rory to look back at the disappointing end to Edinburgh's season and Glasgow's march towards the semi finals.
Gregor Townsend has named a largely experimental squad for the summer tour of the Americas. It's not a question of who misses out, but rather who is actually going, writes Rory.
Iain is joined by Jonny and John to discuss the penultimate round of URC fixtures as well as the recent Scottish Rugby Writers' Awards

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion