Scottish Rugby News and Opinion


Scotland 15-21 Tonga

Scotland v Tonga

In the opening exchanges at a sunny Pittodrie, the early penalties went to Tonga, and  they showed they were here for the result as they opted for kicks at goal despite calls from a well-chilled Aberdeen crowd for more running play, as if the visitors were here only to entertain. Calls that would perhaps come back to haunt them…

There was plenty ambitious play from the Scots, with Henry Pyrgos picking up where he left off against South Africa and keeping the game moving at pace while Laidlaw and Hogg sent probing kicks in behind the bulkier Tongans.

Their big runners like ex Glasgow man Villiami Ma-afu tried to pick out Laidlaw as a target but he was all along the defensive line, unruffled and still willing to tackle props. Neat instinctive running from the Tongan 10 and 12 and some great offloading saw them look dangerous ball in hand.

Scotland though were going low as they were supposed to do the previous week and they put the Tongans under pressure in the ensuing breakdowns, earning penalties.

After one apiece it was 3-3 and despite early promise, the game would remain locked there for quite some time.

Visser learnt his lesson from last weekend and he went looking for work, as did Lamont. Both were key figures for Scotland in the opening 20mins, as was Al Kellock who responded to earning a start with a lot of ball carrying and a commanding performance at the lineout.

Hogg also saw a lot more ball than in previous weeks and the crowd get really buzzed when he, Visser or Lamont get ball in hand. The Tongans tackled manfully though and the backs couldn’t break through.

It was understandable then that Scotland tried to get their maul rolling early on and with some success. Referee Mathieu Raynal went upstairs to the TMO as Scotland crossed, but the score was rejected.

Take two was made a mess of by the Tongans but Scotland earned another penalty, while the third attempt was held up by the defence. The Scots were determined they would have the points, went for the scrum but came away unsuccessful. Sound familiar?

While scoring tries was as usual Scotland’s problem, discipline was Tonga’s main fault, with a sin-binning from the lineout and their tighthead Aulika lucky not to go for a shoulder barge on Matt Scott shortly thereafter.

It seemed like Scotland were in control without ever really making it count on the scoreboard , Laidlaw kicking a penalty in the dying moments of the half to finally reflect the lead that Scotland deserved. Tonga almost had the last word with a scorching break from full back Lilo that luckily ended up in touch.

It was a poor first half on the scoreboard and Scotland felt like they weren’t far from clicking. Tonga as a supposed minnow would have been happy: they were still in it.

Scotland came out in the second half and attacked, as a great break from Lamont saw them inside Tonga’s 22 but again Scotland were unable to make the last pass.

Too many technical errors at set piece from both sides kept the game in stop start mode, althout murray and gray/kellock had edge at scrum and lineout respectively

With Laidlaw’s third penalty Scotland were still in the lead but would have really been thinking they should have had a try by now. Tonga would have been thinking a try of their own would put them in the driving seat.

They kept trying until Lokotui piled over following a scrum close to the Scotland line. It went to the TMO again but this time the score was awarded. The kick was good and the score was 9-10, with the visitors in the lead for first time.

On Scotland’s next possession Lamont had to be restrained from taking a quick tap but Laidlaw kicked Scotland back in the lead 12-10, and then again minutes later to make it 15-10.

Tonga were playing the scoreboard game too as they kicked a penalty in front of posts. Still playing it sensible; still far from over.

As if to prove this once and for all, another scorching break from Vainikolo set the cat well amongst the pigeons as his pace proved too much for Scotland and he dove over for a great solo try. With the try marked up on Pittodrie’s fairly useless scoreboard and dangerously little time to play, the score was 15-18.

After Tonga had their captain Nili Latu sin-binned for trying to climb on top of a maul, first cap Tom Heathcote kicked for goal but fell just short. Not his ideal start I am sure, but he looked assured running the backline in the late stages of the game.

Could Tonga overcome that Pacific instinct and play stodgy keep ball to run out the clock? As it happens they didn’t have to, as errors stayed in Scotland’s ball retention and Tonga were able to keep the pressure on.

A lazy penalty was greeted with a lazy kick from the Tongan fly half Apikotoa but it still sidled through the posts to make it 15-21.

Scotland attacked well again through the excellent Hogg and the ever-present Lamont but the Tongan defence was up to it until the inevitable penalty was coughed up by the home side.

It happened again after another period of strong Scottish pressure, but then Timani’s silly single-handed upending of Lawson after the whistle had blown almost undid all Tonga’s good work. He was sent to the bin and Scotland went looking for the 7-pointer that would get them out of jail.

From the resulting 5 metre lineout Tonga gifted more silly penalties and the Aberdeen crowd had their hackles up as they urged their team towards an unlikely victory.

With time all but up on the clock, Scotland had a scrum to get them their try, but despite repeated penalties they were unable to make it count, as was the case all through the game. With the lottery of the scrums these days, is it really a better option to keep taking them than to take a tap and go?

Almost inevitably Tonga pinched the ball from the base, broke upfield and it was all over.

Stuart Hogg in particular showed today what the jersey means to him and he was visibly shattered afterwards as the very small Tongan section of the Pittodrie crowd went into party mode with their team, leaving the Scots to pick up the pieces once again.

Attendance: 20,306

9 Responses

  1. Time for Andy Robinson to go, he can get us wins half way around the world but that counts for nothing if there are no results at home. Robinson out, Lineen in.

  2. I’m so disappointed with the way the boys are playing. I have said it is their fault not playing as a team but now I feel it is more from the caching side of the team. They are failing us.

  3. I am at my wits end with how inept Scotland are these days. How much are these “pro” players paid anyway? Are they incapable of executing the most basic skills: taking and givin a pass, running straight from deep, passing out of a tackle, tackling and getting back up again! Too many poor players walking into this team and showing no talent whatsoever, its an insult to ex players like rutherford, irvine, hastings, townsend, brown, armstrong, etc. i dont blame robinson as he clearly cant be coaching them to be shite! The players are obviously just not listening to him. Then again, he is the one picking them and showing FAR too much loyalty. The players need to look long and hard at themselves, watch a few all black matches and ask themselves if they are doing their best to at least try and play that way, even if they dont match it. All we ask is to see some effort, passion and a little bit of ability.
    No more rubbish from Strokosh, Lamont, Kellock, Gray (massively overrated prettyboy!), Murray, Laidlaw (out of his depth), and several others. Time for a massive overhaul of the whole squad and for a root and branch review of coaching at all levels (is Wayne Smith available for a year or two?).

  4. A grim day for scottish rugby.its just not good enough.fortress pittrodie i dont think so.there now needs to be a complete revision of our coaching structure.andy robinson cannot continue to offer these mediocre results.time for a change.

  5. About three years ago I went to see the Miami Dolphins play at their stadium. I had not really followed American football but the one clear observation was that every single play had a clear objective and that everyone new what their role was to execute that play. I say this as it is blindingly obvious that Scotland (under Robinson’s tenure and especially at home) have unclear play objectives and the squad cannot execute as a team. We are in a very diificult place at the moment and it is only going to get harder.

    We have simply not progressed despite the summer wins. On the pitch, decision making seems poor and the players rarely seem to get rewarded despite their the physical efforts. We lack direction and as we have the players we have, how do we get more out of them? Robinson has to step down now and give someone new a go at the six nations. Preferably someone who has worked with winning teams at international level, focuses on the basics and that can lift their collective confidence …. which is low and getting lower.

    – Hogg ran well
    – scrum half got faster ball out
    – line out worked ok

    – laidlaw is in the wrong role
    – support on breaks was poor (I think this is fitness related as well as game sense)
    – execution through phases lacked purpose
    – we don’t seem to be street smart any more

    – poor clarity of purpose, players who consistently underperform, poor on pitch

  6. AMW: great contribution! I would add that some of Andy Robinson’s man management has left me cold. I thought his treatment of Mike Blair last week was shocking; Allan Jacobsen’s retirement and comments make me suspicious, his visible rages must be demoralising to players, his half time team talks are disastrous – invariably we start poorly – and his selections inconsistent. He has produced fit and physical sides but without guile. I hope he resigns gracefully and that we appoint a Scot.

  7. So Andy Robinson does the ‘decent’ thing, now where do we go from here?Scotland can’t afford the top coaching team that is required. Even if Wayne Smith or someone of that calibre was appointed how quickly could he raise us to the standards required to achieve success. I mean success as in just at least being consistently able to give the top eight sides tough games. The SRU stated aim of winning the next World Cup is a joke and an insult to all supporters who have shown loyalty beyond measure in turning up in their thousands to watch unacceptable levels of play

  8. I think that defeat was all to do with AR. The kick chases were poor and there were way too many of them (I swear I will tear my hair out and the next pointless box kick). We played predictably and only really off the 9 and the forwards lacked their usual intensity. I think the lack of an opeside really hurt as well.
    It does annoy me that lamont, visser and hogg are all so talented but never work together, they always see how far they get on their own. If they started to work off each other I think we will be in business.
    Now time to get a real coach and see if he can get teh best out of a great bunch of lads!

  9. To start winniing the Scottish rugby establishment and team must stop making statments like “there are a lot of positives we can take from the latest defeat”.Have you ever heard an all black spout such nonesense?. There are not any positives in losing, except,perversely, the one positive that the Scottish team members can take from the latest run of defeats, that there are not better players available to replace them!.

You might also like these:

Craig is joined by John on the injured reserve list to have a wee look at the URC action from the weekend.
World Rugby has taken steps to ban Dupont's Law amongst three new law changes to be brought in in July.
Scotland came up frustratingly short in their final Six Nations match against Ireland, losing out on a place in WXV1 in the dying minutes. It was a disappointing end to what has been a very good, if not spectacular, tournament from Scotland. Eleanor has the talking points.
Scotland's Womens Six Nations came to a frustrating end with an eminently achievable third place slipping out of their fingers in the final minutes. Skye rates the players.

Scottish Rugby News and Opinion